We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.
Friends who know Phuket

Favorites (0)

Connect with friends - see if Phuket is one of their favorites.

Can Advise Me (0)

Connect with friends - see if they have advice on Phuket.

Been There (0)

Connect with friends - see if they've been to Phuket.

Going There (0)

Connect with friends - see if they're going to Phuket.

Free Newsletter

Interested in Phuket?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Phuket each week.

Phuket Forum: Koi Samui vs Phuket


TripAdvisor™ Best Phuket Travel Deals

www.Hyatt.com/ClassicFamilyVacation Free Breakfast, 50% Off Your Second Room & Discounted Activities!
HolidayInn.com Book online or call 877-270-6397
Expedia.com Photos, Reviews and the Guaranteed Lowest Prices

Sign in / Register
 
Phuket Forum
Phuket Destination Experts
  • Members who are knowledgeable about this destination and volunteer their time to answer travelers' questions.
Cathy&Gary
Cathy&Gary
Posts: 3,944
Ring0
Ring0
Posts: 986
Phuket experts wanted. Know someone? Tell us.
Kata_noi
Kata_noi
Posts: 385
stevenl
stevenl
Posts: 1,063
fiddledude
fiddledude
Posts: 226
JamieMonk
Posts: 192
KingFisher8888
Posts: 203
Hide
Search in: 

Watch This Topic Post a new topicReply to this post
 Pages: 1 2  Next>>
   Chicago, Illinois
   Joined: Jul 2007
   Forum posts: 10
   Travel map pins: 167 

Posted on: 4:35 pm,January 06, 2009
Save Save

I am wanting to visit Thailand again this May for two weeks. My husband and I just like to relax, maybe play some tennis but really don't care about nightlife etc. We like secluded and quiet resorts.

We went to Phuket in October, and stayed at the JW Marriott where we had a lovely time. Our only complaint was that the beach was useless. You could walk for a little while but no one could ever go in the water, and there weren't even chairs or anything set up. It was pretty, but somewhat disappointing.

We did enjoy ourselves soo much that we are discussing just returning to this resort. However, I am wondering if anyone else has been to the JW and the Marriott resort on Koi Samui? I would love to know if anyone thinks Koi Samui would be a better choice, or if we should stick with the JW? Any info would be appreciated.

Thanks!!!

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Sydney
   Joined: Dec 2008
   Forum posts: 26
   Travel map pins: 164 

DeeDeePop
Posted on: 5:40 pm,January 06, 2009
Save Save

KS has some good beaches - if you like strolling along the beach and swimming. There is no surf on the two beaches i know at Chaweng (them main town) or Boh Phut (my favourite place).

There are several quiet resorts on KS - a few of the better ones are around Boh Phut and then there are a few more expensive places like the Evason and Four Seasons which look great, have loads of facilities but are quite pricy.

I have not been to the Marriot at KS, we have staye several times at the Anantara - a smaller resort at Boh Phut which we like - it is quiet and a 10 min stroll to Fishermans Village where there are a dozen or so restaurants so you dont have to be stuck eating at the resort all the time. They have sun loungers on a smal stretch of beach in fornt of their resort.

Chaweng is a nosier town but there are many resorts on the beach that could be worth investigating.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Chicago, Illinois
   Joined: Jul 2007
   Forum posts: 10
   Travel map pins: 167 

Posted on: 6:01 pm,January 06, 2009
Save Save

Do you happen to know if the Marriott on KS is secluded, the only hotel in the area, or on that beach?

I am not a fan of beaches where there are 10 hotels in a row and people are strolling from hotel to hotel. We like to be completely secluded from other hotels.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   margaret river,wa
   Joined: Sep 2008
   Forum posts: 24
   Travel map pins: 3 

Posted on: 6:11 pm,January 06, 2009
Save Save

what about indigo pearl, phuket? its a beautiful resort. unless you are wanting KS.

we are going on thursday.

conde naste rated them number 1 hotel and they are number 1 on tripadvisor.

we will be 45min out of patong.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Sydney
   Joined: Dec 2008
   Forum posts: 26
   Travel map pins: 164 

DeeDeePop
Posted on: 6:52 pm,January 06, 2009
Save Save

The Four Seasons on Kohn Samui might suit you - it is more secluded but quite expensive - looks superb though.

I am currently looking at the Kambalya - again not cheap, but a little more secluded. Will let you know if I stay there - plannig on going to KS in Feb.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Miranda, Sydney
   Joined: Sep 2006
   Forum posts: 1,135
   Travel map pins: 16 

SandyL
Posted on: 7:10 pm,January 06, 2009
Save Save

Hi There,

If you want a lovely beach - the New Star Resort is just around the corner from Chaweng beach - had a look in April, and all of the rooms are lovely, especially the sea villas - and of course, the most expensive bungalow villas on the beach. The pool was lovely, and I doubt if anyone except the resort guests would use the beach. Tennis court - I don't think so, but is worth investigating.

Southern Chaweng beach is fantastic - we stayed at Samui Paradise Chaweng, which is just gorgeous, but it is a small resort with a small pool, but beautiful villa suites directly fronting the beach. But again, no tennis court.

Personally, I would not stay at Bophut (although some of the resorts are lovely) as the beach is not that great.

Phuket v Koh Samui - have been to Phuket 5 times & Koh Samui twice - and WILL DEFINITELY GO TO KOH SAMUI AGAIN!

Have fun deciding.

Cheers,

Sandy

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   brisbane
   Joined: Jan 2007
   Forum posts: 215
   Travel map pins: 64 

PrincessPete
Posted on: 9:11 pm,January 06, 2009
Save Save

Hi

We were in Phuket in Oct as well and stayed at Mom Tri Villa Royale on Kata Noi Beach. This beach is just lovely. We had great swimming conditions, was able to snorkel around the rocks on the headland, plenty of beach loungers, and no hawkers to bother you.

So maybe try another beach area in Phuket?

The other issue is that May is the beginning of the green season in Phuket, and the sea can get a bit churned up making if unsafe to swim. Maybe the season is more favourable in Koh Samui then?

I have not been to KS but have been doing some research on it. Sth Chaweng area & Chaweng Noi Beach appears to have the best swimming conditions so we are looking there as an alternative to Phuket.

Cheers

Pete

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Solihull, West Mids
   Joined: Jul 2004
   Forum posts: 671
   Travel map pins: 60 

Posted on: 5:24 am,January 07, 2009
Save Save

We went to Koh Samui two years ago and stayed at the Imperial Samui. It was beautiful. It was outside of chaweng so not in the middle of the all the night life but easily accessible if you want it. There were three beautiful beach restaurants which we visited just a little walk down on the beach from the Imperial and the food was to die for and dirt cheap. We are going to Phuket this April and having never been there before are hoping we enjoy it as much as Koh Samui.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   australia
   Joined: Jun 2008
   Forum posts: 434
   Travel map pins: 29 

Posted on: 9:25 am,January 07, 2009
Save Save

Hi do what we are doing in July, 1 week in patong (which we have been to twice before) and then we are doing a week in Koh Samui, horses for courses some say Phuket some Say Koh samui, opinions are like bums everyone has one, I tend to do it for myself then Im sure im not making a decision on someone elses taste

Enjoy! thats the main thing

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Coffs Harbour Australia
   Joined: May 2007
   Forum posts: 406
   Travel map pins: 50 

Posted on: 7:28 pm,January 08, 2009
Save Save

Hi Sandy,

We're thinking of staying at the New Star Resort later this year, its a bit pricey but you get what you pay for (I hope) Can you tell me how long it takes to walk up the beach to everything? I know its located at Chaweng Noi from memory the beach here is actually better than most of Chaweng Beach?

Thanks

Coffs

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Miranda, Sydney
   Joined: Sep 2006
   Forum posts: 1,135
   Travel map pins: 16 

SandyL
Posted on: 8:22 pm,January 08, 2009
Save Save

Hi Coffs,

Did you end up going to Ho Chi Minh?

Anyway, the walk from Samui Paradise Chaweng is about 15 minutes at a leisurely pace - it is a very big resort, but the beach looked lovely & also the pool. It does take a few minutes to finally reach reception - you need to walk down a pathway for a while before you reach it. One of the staff took me around in a buggy (like on Hamilton Island) and showed me some of the rooms. But only the seaview rooms & beach bungalows were close to the pool/beach.

You would definitely need a scooter or songtiew to get into the main part of Chaweng.

Hope this helps,

Sandy (less than 3 months till we leave for our big VN trip)

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate

TripAdvisor™ Best Phuket Travel Deals

www.Hyatt.com/ClassicFamilyVacation Free Breakfast, 50% Off Your Second Room & Discounted Activities!
HolidayInn.com Book online or call 877-270-6397
Expedia.com Photos, Reviews and the Guaranteed Lowest Prices