IBEROSTAR Grand Rose Hall vs IBEROSTAR Grand Hotel Paraíso

I've been to the grand in Riviera Maya, needless to say the service and food was top notch.. Lobster each day for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Buffet was good as well and drinks. Now my question has anyone else been to both of these resorts and which one do you prefer? I'm thinking of trying the one in Montego Bay this year in October I have been to Jamaica before but stayed at the Grand Palladium. Any advice would be great on the Grands as to which one has best service and food .... Thanks