We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

In cooperation with: Visit Mexico
Which Playa del Carmen hotels are on sale?
mm/dd/yyyy mm/dd/yyyy
See hotels
Toronto
posts: 32
reviews: 1
'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

Some might disagree with the info I'm about to provide, but I think it's important that people get an informed (or at least secondary) opinion before buying suitcase loads of vanilla to bring back to family and friends.

I've just returned from the Iberostar Paraiso Beach, and spent a significant amount of time shopping for Vanilla in, around and all over PDC.

Had I beeen on my own, I would likely have been very happy to have bought any of the brands adorning shelves and counters around town. However I was with my wife. Who happens to be a pastry chef. You can imagine that she knows a bit more about vanilla than the average Joe.

Suffice to say, none of what you buy there is the 'famous Mexican Vanilla'. The best of the best comes from the province of Vera Cruz, I think from a town or county called Papantla. You can't get this in PDC. Maybe in Cancun...but not in playa.

You'll get lots from Xel-ha. Some from Xcaret and other places around the country. But it's of a lesser quality. And after tasting it, I'd go as far as to say it's heavily watered down...and some is artifically sweetened.

This might be a bit of a bummer, and I suppose I should qualify what I've said. I saw nothing on 5th avenue. I saw nothing in gift shops at hotels or on Cozumel. I even dragged my wife out of the tourist area and into the grocery stores, pharmacies and convenience-type shops in the 'local' areas of town. Every person said the same thing - 'you can't get it in this part of the country.'

I'm not trying to burst bubbles or call people liars or anything like that. I just know I would have bought all sorts of the stuff if I hadn't married an expert.

My suggestion? Cancun might be a worthwhile trip where you might the real thing. Alternately, seek high and low for a bottle that proudly proclaims Vera Cruz Vanilla (specifically papantla...I'm nott sure if I'm spelling that correctly). Or (if you really want that baking to come out better than anyone elses at the fair) shell out for the really good stuff - tahitian vanilla. It's something like $100 per litre, but worth every drop. Or so the experts say...

Tulum, Mexico
posts: 765
reviews: 1
1. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

You are dead on. We've given up on buying the good stuff in the Yucatan. Not a chef, but we've been happier with the vanilla for Penzeys (US) than anything we've found in Mexico.

Big D
Destination Expert
for Tulum, Dallas
posts: 11,535
reviews: 6
2. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

I've always thought it was not even real vanilla...I thought Madagascar and Tahiti produced the best vanilla.

But thanks for the real story.

Pastry chef...from Toronto?....Regan?

Cozumel, Mexico
Destination Expert
for Cozumel, Merida
posts: 35,860
reviews: 67
3. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

I have bought "real" vanilla at Chedraui in Cozumel. Does Chedraui in Playa not have it? Of course, they always have more of the imitation variety.

Tulum, Mexico
posts: 765
reviews: 1
4. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

We only saw the imitation stuff at the PdC Chedraui, but they could have just been out.

Toronto
posts: 32
reviews: 1
5. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

Wow. I really thought I'd be brow-beaten for suggesting the vanilla in PDC is inferior. Thanks for the validation.

Pepper - not Regan.

Tulum, Mexico
posts: 765
reviews: 1
6. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

You probably will be, just wait for it ;)

Missouri
posts: 1,556
reviews: 7
7. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

I was in PDC in March, and bought the Xel-Ha brand vanilla. The first ingredient listed is Papantla vanilla beans....haven't tried it yet.

Toronto
posts: 32
reviews: 1
8. Re: 'pure' vanilla...not in PDC

Kinda funny that the Xel-Ha vanilla lists Papantla vanilla beans, no?

Taste it (we did). You'll quickly find that it bears a striking, watery, artifical resemblance to everything else available.