My future wife and I have decided we are going to Honeymoon in St. John in Oct of this year (2011). I have read both good and not-so-good things about both Caneel Bay and The Westin. There is also a significant difference in price, Westin 3 nights: $876.05 for a premium beachfront front room, no food included and Caneel Bay 3 nights: $2,748 for a beachfront room, 3 meals are included. If anyone has stayed at both and could give some insight as to the real "value" you receive for staying at Caneel, it would be appreciated. Yes, this is a Honeymoon and would like some privacy and I am willing to pay the additional amount because quality of beach, water and quiet is important but only if it could truly makes a difference in the experience. $2,000 can purcahse a lot of food and recreation.... Thanks for any and all help!