After several months of deliberation, my wife and I finally booked our villa and flights for next May. Now I have nothing to do for the next 9 months beside starting to think about what to do while we are there.
This is our first visit to St. John, but we were in the BVI a few years ago on a sailing charter. One of our best meals we had was a grilled caribbean lobster dinner at some beach-side "dive" in Great Harbor, Jost Van Dyke. I don't remember the name - other than there was a mural of a donkey painted on the back wall - but the combination of freshed grilled lobster, cold Caribe, and beach side location was perfect.