We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.
Friends who know St. Croix

Favorites (0)

Connect with friends - see if St. Croix is one of their favorites.

Can Advise Me (0)

Connect with friends - see if they have advice on St. Croix.

Been There (0)

Connect with friends - see if they've been to St. Croix.

Going There (0)

Connect with friends - see if they're going to St. Croix.

Free Newsletter

Interested in St. Croix?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for St. Croix each week.

St. Croix Forum: sugar bay vs cottages by the sea


TripAdvisor™ Best St. Croix Travel Deals

www.CheapCaribbean.com/StCroix Sale Ends Sunday - Up to 70% Off Caribbean & Mexico Vacations.
www.bluevistavilla.com Wide ocean views; 4 bdrms, pool, spa, exercise rm, pavillion & more
www.USVirginIslands.BookIt.com $165 Save 60% in US Virgin Islands Book Your Travel in St. Croix!

Sign in / Register
 
St. Croix Forum
St. Croix Destination Experts
  • Members who are knowledgeable about this destination and volunteer their time to answer travelers' questions.
crabgroupie
crabgroupie
Posts: 557
pilotboy
pilotboy
Posts: 584
St. Croix experts wanted. Know someone? Tell us.
futuredolphin
Posts: 525
MargyZ
MargyZ
Posts: 570
stcroixtraveler
Posts: 378
St._Croix_Local
St._Croix_Local
Posts: 169
STX203
STX203
Posts: 151
Hide
Search in: 

Watch This Topic Post a new topic
   vienna, va
   Joined: Nov 2005
   Forum posts: 11
   Travel map pins: 0 

Posted on: 4:14 pm,November 02, 2005
Save Save

we are planning our trip for this Jan or Feb. We have been to St Croix 9 years ago and stayed in a private condo on the north shore and it was very windy. We are taking our 18 mos old and were looking at a first floor condo where we could sit outside in the sun while she is napping. I've seen good and bad reviews on all of the different condos. Anybody have any suggestions?


Report as inappropriate
   San Francisco
   Joined: Nov 2005
   Forum posts: 1
   Travel map pins: 1 

Posted on: 7:51 pm,November 02, 2005
Save Save

Both Cottages by the Sea and Sandcastle on the Beach are on the west end. The water is calmer and little or no wind. Sandcastles have nicer rooms, but Cottages has kitchens. I have stayed at both in the last year and personally perfer Sandcastles (AC makes a diffrence to me) and they also have two pools.


Report as inappropriate
   vienna, va
   Joined: Nov 2005
   Forum posts: 11
   Travel map pins: 0 

Posted on: 10:18 pm,November 02, 2005
Save Save

sand castle on the beach looks nice but the clothing optional pool bothers me. Is it a nice place to stay for families?


Report as inappropriate
   texas
   Joined: Apr 2005
   Forum posts: 381
   Travel map pins: 0 

Posted on: 6:41 pm,November 06, 2005
Save Save

Hi!

I would recommend the Divi. It's on the southeast side of the island. We stayed at Coakley Bay condos in Feb up in the G building and it was VERY windy and cool, but when we drove over to the Divi to use the beach we noticed that there was just a gentle breeze. The rooms open right onto the beach. (They also have some up higher on a hill, so I'd request the beachside ones)

We drove all over the island and looked at several of the condos on the north side. All 'seemed' just fine. Lots of people staying in them all. But I'm not sure about how windy it is to stay there at that time of the year since I wasn't thinking about that at the time--- just how beautiful the view was from that area! I wasn't that impressed with the places to stay on the west side of the island. LOVED the beach there, but I did not want to stay there. That's just me, others like it. You can email me if you want more info. Paula11554@aol


Report as inappropriate
   Hamden, CT
   Joined: Dec 2005
   Forum posts: 287
   Travel map pins: 38 

Posted on: 12:41 pm,December 28, 2005
Save Save

Definately go with Cottages by the Sea. We stayed there Oct'05. All have AC, kitchens and patios where you can sit and listen for your young one to wake up from a nap. The beach is the best for a young one too. We went swimming from early morning to early evening every day. Had planned to go to other beaches but didn't have any reason to.

If you are comparing Sugar BEACH condos, well as they say in realestate, Location is everything.


Report as inappropriate

TripAdvisor™ Best St. Croix Travel Deals

www.CheapCaribbean.com/StCroix Sale Ends Sunday - Up to 70% Off Caribbean & Mexico Vacations.
www.bluevistavilla.com Wide ocean views; 4 bdrms, pool, spa, exercise rm, pavillion & more
www.USVirginIslands.BookIt.com $165 Save 60% in US Virgin Islands Book Your Travel in St. Croix!