We are a married couple in our 30s who are hopefully headed to one of these places in Jan or Feb. We are considering Couples Negril or Sandals in Antigua, but are open to others. We don't want a continious frat part type of atmosphere, but do like it fun and lively. We enjoy dancing, exploring,snorkeling, and beach toys. I was under the impression Jamaica doesn't have as pretty and clear water as other islands, which leans me toward Antigua. Accurate or not? For instance, I was not impressed by the water in St Lucia and it seems that Jamaica's topography might be similiar, darkening the water?? Jamaica sounds like more fun...love reggae and such. Please clarify and help me find a fun, yet romantic island and resort.