We've (along with several family and friends) had pleasant 10 and 11 day stays at Harmony Club over the past few years and will be returning again with family and friends for another 11 day visit next month (even without the 'all-inclusive' rate plan)...so I guess we've been '..voting..' with our wallets. Based on our pleasant experiences, I can't quite reconcile the '..slams..' versus the raves. The '..truth..' probably lies somewhere in between.
The last time the hotel was completely renovated was a little over ten(10) years ago. But every year they pull several rooms out of the inventory at varoius times for renovations. The past couple of years, this rotation/renovation process has been slowed because of (of all things) the success of the property and a desire/need to get several rooms in the previously un-used SUNRISE building (closes to the South Road) into service. They've been working on the SUNRISE building on and off for 2-3 years now. I know that during our 11 day visit last year, two of the ground-floor-center rooms of the BOUGANVILLEA building were temporarily pulled out of the inventory and re-furbished as part of the on-going process while we were there.
If you look at the HARMONY CLUB web site, the rooms pictured with the more '..contenporary..' decor will be located in the three(3) detached buildings at the western end of the property (around the Putting Green)--BOUGANVILLEA, SUNSET and WILD POPPY. All of the rooms in these buildings are more than amply sized, some rooms with two(2) double beds and some with one(1) king, more than ample room for a sitting area with table and chairs and still have room to dance around on the ceramic tile floors throughout. Ground floor rooms in these buildings will have walk-out patios with Hibuscus covered pergulas. Upper floor rooms do not have corresponding terraaces (but room size is identical). If the more '..comtemporary..' decor is more to your liking then ground floor rooms w/patio in these three buildings will probably be best.
The room pictured with the more '..traditional..' decor will be located in the PAGET MANOR '..L..'wing of the hotel. These rooms have both separate outside entrances with 'porches' as well as interior entrances to the main hotel corridoors. These rooms will have eith two doubles or one king, and usually an upolstered love seat, end and coffee tables. In addition to the 'traditional' decor, they will also have polished cedar-plank floors. Of the Paget Manor rooms # 26, 27, 28 and #33 (this is the room pictured with the recessed arch, exterior entry). The other rooms with lower numbers (from 15-t0-25) are a 'mixed bag'. Rooms# 22 & 23 have walk out terraces, but the rooms are on the back-side of the hotel and look out over the tennis courts (and now on-going condo construction) and are perfectlyadequate but really nothing special. The rest of the lower numbered rooms are adequate by nothing to write about.
I haven't seen any of the newly re-finished rooms in the SUNRISE building (so I can't speak with any personal knowledge of them), but we did speak with a couple of guests who had been assigned rooms in this wing last summer and they were not at all '..happy campers..'...even after a few drinks at the bar.