I am sure I replied to this already but can't see where my reply is.
Probably a bit biased, but we are booked in to the Anantara again in June for our 5th stay. The last 3 being in a one bedroom pool villa. Not sure of your budget but I would suggest that one of these would be great for a honeymoon, really well laid out, beautifully presented. Have a look for some photos on the net and you will see what I mean.
Yeah the Hansar looks good, but my opinion is that you feel as you walk down the public road to Fisherman's Village, with people on day beds on the beach from Hansar, on one side of the cobbled road and people on sun lounges on the other side from Hansar, you feel as though you are walking through Hansar itself rather than a public access road to Fisherman's Village, just a bit too open for me.
For a Honeymoon and if you want some real quality and peaceful private time to yourselves, a one bedroom private pool villa at the Anantara would be a great choice.