We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly. We support the following browsers:
"This is such a nice restaurant with great food and a great ambiance. I love coming here especially because they keep open in the winter. Their Crispy Calamari Salad is addictive. One short coming is they don't provide high chairs for kids (which sort of says we don't want kids here ...) Love coming ..."back every time.
" More >
"Get the mussels, get the profiteroles. So awesome. They had a great wine list, the service was quick and polite- our server even gave us a free dessert when we couldn't decide on what we wanted! We would definitely brave the East End traffic, just for the day so we could eat here again. 2 thumbs up!"
"I came from East Hampton, we put the car on the boat around sunset and then drove to the restaurant when we got on to Shelter Island. The atmosphere is great! Really like this place. We had a slight mosquito issue but that wasn't there problem. The food was 4 out of 5 but the service was very good a..."nd I think few would be disappointed here. Take it for what it is, you aren't in NYC, enjoy the scenery!
" More >
TripAdvisor™ provides unbiased reviews, articles, recommendations and opinions on Shelter Island restaurants.
Reviews and advice on hotels, resorts, flights, vacation rentals, travel packages, and lots more!