We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Best Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Your filters are still active.
There are no pins in your viewport. Try moving the map or changing your filters.
Sorted by:
Ranking
Name
Price (low to high)
Price (high to low)

18 Bay

#1 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $25 - $100 Map
Visitor photos (9)
Cuisines: Italian
Reserve

Commander Cody's

#2 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (6)

Marie Eiffel Market

#3 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $5 - $30 Map
Visitor photos (28)
Cuisines: American Cafe Sandwiches Delicatessen Bagels

Vine Street Cafe

#4 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $41 - $80 Map
Visitor photos (5)
Menu
Cuisines: American
Reserve

Rams Head Inn Restaurant

#5 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $30 Map
Visitor photos (15)
Menu
Cuisines: American

Stars Cafe

#6 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (6)
Menu

Salt

#7 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (6)
Menu
Cuisines: American

Clark's Fish House

#8 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (9)
Menu
Cuisines: Seafood

The Pridwin Restaurant

#9 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $40
Visitor photos (6)
Menu
Cuisines: Seafood American

Maria's kitchen

#10 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu
Cuisines: Mexican

The Tavern at Shelter Island House

#11 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $30 Map
Visitor photos (7)
Menu
Cuisines: French

Sweet Tomato's

#12 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $7 - $32 Map
Visitor photos (4)
Menu
Cuisines: Italian American

The Islander

#13 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $5 - $20 Map
Visitor photos (3)
Menu
Cuisines: Diner

Vue Restaurant

#14 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (6)
Menu
Cuisines: American

Sunset Beach

#15 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $31 - $50 Map
Visitor photos (9)
Menu
Reserve

Tuck Shop

#16 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu

Chequit Inn

#17 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $15 - $30 Map Menu
Cuisines: Contemporary

Bella Vita Pizz

#18 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map Menu
Cuisines: Italian Pizza

Eagle Deli

#19 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map Menu

Kyle's

#20 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (4)
Menu
Cuisines: American

Shelter Island Bake Shop

#21 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map Menu

Pat & Steve's Family Restaurant

#22 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map Menu
Cuisines: Diner

Island Cafe

#23 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map Menu

Dory

#24 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (11)
Menu

Denny's

#25 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Menu
Cuisines: American

Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy (Shelter Island Heights)

#26 of 27 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map Menu