We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Best Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

I like:
Online reservations
American
Italian
Seafood
Cheap eats
Mid-range
Fine dining
$-$$$$
Price
Cuisine
Dining options
Sorted by:
Ranking Name Price (low to high) Price (high to low) Friends first
#1 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Map | Visitor photos (6)
#2 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $25 - $100
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (9)
Reserve
#3 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $5 - $30
Cuisines: American, Coffee Shop, Sandwiches, Delicatessen, Bagels
Map | Visitor photos (28)
#4 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $41 - $80
Cuisines: American
Map | Visitor photos (5) | Menu
Reserve
#5 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Map | Visitor photos (6)
#6 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $30
Cuisines: American
Map | Visitor photos (15) | Menu
#7 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: Seafood
Map | Visitor photos (9)
#8 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: American
Map | Visitor photos (6)
#9 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $40
Cuisines: Seafood, American
Visitor photos (6)
#10 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $7 - $32
Cuisines: Italian, American
Map | Visitor photos (4)
#11 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $30
Cuisines: French
Map | Visitor photos (7) | Menu
#12 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: Mexican
Map | Visitor photos (1)
#13 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Map
#14 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $31 - $50
Map | Visitor photos (7) | Menu
Reserve
#15 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $15 - $30
Cuisines: Contemporary
Map | Menu
#16 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
#17 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: American
Map | Visitor photos (6)
#18 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $5 - $20
Cuisines: Diner
Map | Visitor photos (3)
#19 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: Dessert
Map | Visitor photos (1)
#20 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: American
Map | Visitor photos (4)
#21 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
#22 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: Diner
Map
#23 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
#24 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Cuisines: American
Map | Menu
#25 of 26 restaurants in Shelter Island
Map | Visitor photos (11) | Menu
Be the first to review this restaurant
Address: 2520 E. Dixon Blvd, Shelter Island, NY 28150
Cuisines: American