We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Best Long Island Italian Restaurants

Restaurants
 
Dessert
 
Coffee & Tea
 
Bakeries
 
Ice Cream
 
Waffles & Crepes
 
Juice & Smoothies
 
$-$$$$
Price
1
Cuisine
Dining options
Sorted by:
Ranking Name Price (low to high) Price (high to low) Friends first
The Trattoria (Saint James)
#4 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 50 Restaurants in Saint James
Price: $31 - $50
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (7) | Menu
#5 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 18 Restaurants in Ocean Beach
Price: $17 - $32
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza, Seafood, Pizza & Pasta, Healthy
Map | Visitor photos (6) | Menu
#6 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 73 Restaurants in Deer Park
Price: $17 - $30
Cuisines: Italian, Wine Bar, Eclectic
Map | Visitor photos (15) | Menu
Reserve
Orto (Miller Place)
#9 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 35 Restaurants in Miller Place
Price: $31 - $50
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (5) | Menu
#10 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 31 Restaurants in Islip
Price: $20 - $100
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (4) | Menu
Maria's (Nesconset)
#15 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 22 Restaurants in Nesconset
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (5) | Menu
#19 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 79 Restaurants in Port Washington
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Map | Visitor photos (3) | Menu
Restaurant Joanina (Huntington)
#26 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 183 Restaurants in Huntington
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (5) | Menu
#27 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#2 of 57 Restaurants in East Hampton
Cuisines: Italian, Delicatessen
Map | Visitor photos (1) | Menu
Edge Water Restaurant (Hampton Bays)
#30 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 66 Restaurants in Hampton Bays
Price: $10 - $40
Cuisines: Italian, Seafood
Map | Visitor photos (10) | Menu
#33 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 87 Restaurants in Massapequa
Cuisines: Italian, Japanese, Sushi, Spanish, Tapas, Wine Bar
Map | Visitor photos (10) | Menu
18 Bay (Shelter Island)
#43 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 25 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price: $25 - $100
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (9)
Reserve
Cara Mia (Seaford)
#46 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 42 Restaurants in Seaford
Price: $15 - $30
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (5)
#48 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#2 of 60 Restaurants in Hauppauge
Price: $25
Cuisines: Italian, Seafood
Map | Menu
Pasta Pasta (Port Jefferson)
#51 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#4 of 47 Restaurants in Port Jefferson
Price: $10 - $25
Cuisines: Italian, Continental, Pasta
Map | Visitor photos (5) | Menu
Reserve
King Umberto (Elmont)
#59 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 32 Restaurants in Elmont
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (3) | Menu
Reserve
Filomena's Restaurant (Franklin Square)
#67 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 47 Restaurants in Franklin Square
Cuisines: Italian
Map
Branchinelli's (Hauppauge)
#68 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#4 of 60 Restaurants in Hauppauge
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Map | Visitor photos (4)
Cafe Baci (Westbury)
#71 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 88 Restaurants in Westbury
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (6) | Menu
#80 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 76 Restaurants in New Hyde Park
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Map | Menu
Umberto's (New Hyde Park)
#81 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#2 of 76 Restaurants in New Hyde Park
Price: $15 - $20
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Map | Visitor photos (17) | Menu
Reserve
La Piccola Liguria (Port Washington)
#83 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#2 of 79 Restaurants in Port Washington
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (1)
Giulio & Cesare (Westbury)
#85 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#2 of 88 Restaurants in Westbury
Cuisines: Italian
Map
Ponte Mollo (Great Neck)
#95 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 91 Restaurants in Great Neck
Price: $20 - $30
Cuisines: Italian, Tapas, Wine Bar
Map | Visitor photos (24) | Menu
Reserve
#96 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#2 of 69 Restaurants in Glen Cove
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (3)
Cafe Formaggio (Westbury)
#97 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#3 of 88 Restaurants in Westbury
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (9) | Menu
#100 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#3 of 76 Restaurants in New Hyde Park
Price: $30
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (4)
Reserve
#101 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 33 Restaurants in Holbrook
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Map | Visitor photos (7) | Menu
Ciro's (Hauppauge)
#104 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#5 of 60 Restaurants in Hauppauge
Price: $30
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (1)
Reserve
La Volpe Ristorante (Center Moriches)
#110 of 6,049 Restaurants in Long Island
#1 of 18 Restaurants in Center Moriches
Price: $25 - $35
Cuisines: Italian
Map | Visitor photos (3) | Menu
Reserve