We had a large party of 12, so we called ahead to see if they could seat us since they do take reservations. They said it would be able to seat us in 20 minutes. We waited an hour to get a table. We should have left but every time we inquired about our table, they assured us it would... More

We had both the sicilian and thin crust pizzas. Both were really tasty. Place is very popular so we had to wait for a table, but service was reasonable, given the place was packed. Some of the better pizza I have had in a long time.

We found La Bella Italia after a craving for Italian was unsatisfied by wandering around downtown. We hoped on here and found that La Bella was within walking distance of us but far enough from downtown to be quieter. We got there to find it quiet busy and we ended up waiting about an hour but had a good conversation... More

I visited La Bella Italia after reading reviews and I was blown away. The food was fantastic. We went on a Friday night and had to wait, but took it as a good sign. The red sauce was delicious, along with the bread and the cannoli. I will definitley go back next time I'm in Gettysburg.

Decided to try La Bella after reading some reviews and overall it was a very good experience. Portions were big and the food tasty. My wife ordered the lasagna which she liked and I ordered the small stromboli which was big and very good. This is a very good place to eat in Gettysburg.

Nothing fancy but friendly staff and good food. The pizza was pretty good and I consider myself a jaded New Yorker when it comes to pizza. Good value.

We have been to La Bella's many times. The food has never disappointed, and the pizza is to die for. We have also tried their subs (on delicious homemade bread) and stromboli's. This is a must stop everytime we visit. Just beware parking and the restaurant can get a little crowded on weekends.

Loved this restaurant! Food was authentic, tasty and hot! Caesar salad was delicious! I like that you can bring your own wine, it made for a longer dinner experience which I prefer.

It's by far the best Pizza in Gettysburg. Having grown up eating Apizza at the real mecca's of great Apizza on Wooster Street in New Haven I know what real Pizza should taste like. This place makes a pie that is at least edible. That is high praise for a town that has some of the worst pizza on earth.