My son was graduating from college and we were searching high and low for a restaurant to have a celebratory meal with 7 people. Other local restaurants declined our request for a reservation, as their seating wouldn't allow for 7. We had made this reservation abt a month earlier - Sue (the restaurant manager) called to let us know that... More

I was skeptical based on other reviews but the dinner was amazing. I had the Kobe beef and it was cooked to perfection. The only thing I found expensive was the wine list. Everything else seemed to be inline with fine dining. The service was great. People have commented that the service was too slow but I found it to... More

Food was just OK and the atmosphere is nothing like the Farnsworth or Dobbin House. My prime rib was undercooked. The place is quite stuffy and the food portions were small. Wouldn't go back

We have dined at Herr Tavern twicew before during other visits to Gettsysburg. WHile my wife's meal was good, my "Prime Rib" was a couple of slabs of Serloin Roast that were rare but without a drop of juice. Clearly they had been cooked the day (or two) before and gived a semi- warm up. It was a Friday night... More

I live near Gettysburg and have tried most of the restaurants there and in its surrounding areas. This past Sunday, I took relatives there to celebrate a birthday. We did not have reservations, but we went early. We were welcomed with enthusiasm. The server was so pleasant and helpful. And the food was - well - awesome. Hot homemade bread... More

The Inn at Herr Ridge aims to please. Two couples had a wonderful dinner in this lovely historic area. Each of us enjoyed our meals to varying degrees. There's a limited, but excellent menu. The extensive wine list far exceeds the food selection. Expect to pay more than you should for the wine. The white beet salad was was fabulous... More

I planned this event as a capstone for a group of friends ( 11) enjoying a day of touring on the battlefield. Made reservations months in advance. We were stuffed at a side room at a table elbow to elbow and informed that a big wedding was dominating the rest of the place. Service went straight downhill from that point.... More

We were told this was a local favorite and has rave reviews. Here is my experience. We had a 7pm reservation and showed up on time. We checked in and received a warm welcome. We were asked to wait by the fireplace next to a table of diners. We were given a glass of champagne because we were dressed up... More

Very enjoyable evening, historical inn,declious dinner,red trout was excellent, varied menu,scenic view.Will look forward to returning.