Most restaurants around Broadway are tourist-trap rip-offs with mediocre food. I was delighted to find La Masseria, a real gem. The room is nicely decorated in "country Italian" style. It is a bit noisy and bustling, but not unpleasantly so. Our waiter was very pleasant and attentive. My husband had one of the day's specials, grilled bronzino, our friend had... more

Great after-theatre choice. Still family-run, excellent cuisine. more

We are a tough group to please. I tend toward the gourmet, my husband toward pizza of any caliber, and my daughters toward vegetarian or low-fat/calorie. We were all able to find entrees that we loved, and after tasting each one of them, I can attest to the amazing quality of each. We started with the fried zucchini which was... more

We went to La Masseria twice during our stay at NY and we were impressed by the quality of the food. Lots of restaurants are supposely cooking italian food though its the american interpretation of what is italian food. We were very pleased it tasted like what we ate when we went to Italy last year and the service was... more

Found this lovely, "find" kind of place after we checked into our Hilton Garden Inn just around the corner. The front entrance has an extra cold air buffer door which makes the dining room more comfortable in winter. We like window tables and had the best table in the place-no drafts. The waiter was happy to serve us-had good recommendations,... more

I met my two girlfriends who live in NYC for lunch before a play. The hostess was very personable and the wait staff was exceptional. We got the appetizer special of prosciutto, tomato and the freshest, yummiest mozzarella we have ever eaten, and believe me, the three of us dine out at fine dining constantly. Everything else we ordered was... more

recommended by locals i met in capri more

One of the best restaurants in the city. Impeccable wine list, great service and the food is phenomenal more

Had dinner here with my husband and a friend in early July. We ordered the bucatini, gnocchi and the risotto special. All were fantastic, although the bucatini vecchia roma was the favorite. The service was also impeccable. A great place for dinner before a show or any time you're in the mood for great Italian food. Highly recommended. more