My friend and I ate at Gallagher's in Times Square last night. The service was abysmal. The waiter didn't offer us a wine list and didn't even know if there were any specials. My steak arrived WAY overdone. I ordered a filet medium well and it was dry and burnt. When I voiced my displeasure the waiter seemed surprised. They... more

The bartender was very pleasant and made a great cocktail, but once we were seated it was all down hill. Squeezed between 2 bus stations conversation was impossible. It was clear our waiter wanted us to quickly order and get us fed and out. We never even got the bread basket. The food was OK, but priced as if it... more

Classic New York steak house... Great dinner! more

Sat us right on top of the wait staff area, so it was so loud we couldn't carry on a conversation. Food was good, but a bit overpriced. The add-ons should have been included with a steak meal. more

I saw this place on a trip to NYC a year ago and was dying to try it based on the look of the aging beef through the window. I was there on business 11/13/09 and remembered the name and called for a reservation. Got right in. Atmoshpere was promising for a stuffy, old NYC style steakhouse. A colleague and... more

My mom and I went on 20 Oct 2009 since she wanted to try dry aged beef. I ordered the rib eye, she got the filet. Even though we ordered medium, the meat came out completely charcoaled black on both sides, overwhelming whatever flavor the meat may have had. Her baked potato was $9, my side of creamed spinach was... more

One of our party had eaten in the Las Vegas Gallaghers earlier this year and had a great experience. Unfortunately for us the New York restaurant was a big disapointment and an even bigger waste of money. The waiter barely spoke English and got our drinks order wrong and forgot one drink altogether. The steaks were average but the side... more

Last night, my husband and I went to Gallagher's Steak House in Times Square since we were in that neighborhood and looking for a nice meal. We did not have reservations. No problem, since the place was empty. The place was dirty, a fly in my water and more buzzing around my nose. The bread tasted questionable and the paper... more

years ago I had a bitter discussion with a gallagher's waiter about the tip and I decided non to come back again. this winter, discussing with a friend about NY restaurants we agreed on he same impression about the place: it is going down, year after year. I don't know why I came back but in august I was at... more