When not feeling like a big sit-down meal, but wanting something more than fast food, this is one of our go-to places in the Theater District. Close to Times Square and many Broadway theaters, the food is good (but not great), the service is fast (but not particularly attentive), and the pricing is reasonable for that area. A large loaf... More

Ate there after seeing Phantom of the Opera across the street. Ordered a large Margherita pizza with broccoli and chicken (extra cost). The pizza was hard, cold and almost tasteless. There was barely any tomato sauce and cheese, and the baker forgot to add the basil, so the waitress ended up smothering the pizza with chopped basil leaves. My dinner... More

The one question we asked everyone we met from NYC was "where's the best pizza?". No one ever said John's Pizzeria but we thought we'd try it anyway since it was close by our hotel. As stated in other reviews, ambiance and overall setting were nice. We asked to be seated upstairs so we could take everything in and were... More

Came here based on TA reviews. It was Easter Monday and the place was packed. Given a number and tried to make our way to the bar. Waited about 35mins to be seated. Make sure you allow for waiting time. Once we were seated service was quick and efficient. Ordered a small pizza and that was enough for the two... More

We got the small and antipasti salad. Both were very good and pricing was reasonable. Waiter was very good and laid back. Decor is nice as well. Great location before/after Broadway show.

Great authentic Italian in a wonderful old world feel building. Just west of times square but worth the walk. Very good value. Excellent desserts as well.

So when I arrived at this restaurant I was absolutely starving...meaning that I would eat just about anything! After having my breakfast at 4:30am in Miami it was 2:00pm and I had not eaten anything. It was a Saturday afternoon and it was not very full. My boyfriend and I, along with his parents and brother ordered the garlic rolls... More

Just grabbed a bite before a show across the street. Good service, great pizza. Very big space so no wait for a table. Great for families.

Right off Times Square in the heart of the theater district Johns is as good as it gets. The venue is a great place to people watch and the pizza is fantastic. We had the Johns Traditional which was a perfect combination of Cheese and sauce and crust. Try it. You cannot go wrong.