I have given this restaurant stars in every category but a 4 overall because of one minor matter. The room, the food, the value and the service were all excellent. Elegant but not stuffy. I felt that not enough time was left between courses. Perhaps this actually earns high points from most Americans but for my wife and I some... more

The food, the service, the atmosphere. A little on the pricey side but most times you get what you pay for. Add it all together and you have a wonderful evening. We will go back. Enjoy. more

We chose to dine at Scalini Fedeli based on other great reviews on TA. We had an absolutely amazing experience. The restaurant is very quiet with great background music and perfect lighting. Our waiter, Sebastian, was wonderful and the food is just exceptional. We shared each other's appetizer, entree and dessert just to keep trying each delicious dish. And every... more

found this restaurant on Zagat.com. Fantastic food, earnest service, wide wine list although some selections are pricy, overall exquisite atmosphere, a little on the loud side at 7:30 on Sat. night, but food is fantastic. WARNING- restaurants are down a steep flight of stairs, which could be a problem. I was 10 weeks from knee replacement surgery and it was... more

Consistently outstanding in both food and service. Perhaps the best Italian in New York. more

This is one place everyone should try. The best Italian food I've had so far. more

wonderful food and you get soo much more

My partner and I decided to try this restaurant based on all the favorable reviews from others on Trip Advisor. The restaurant is beautiful and the service and food were outstanding. Based on prior reviews, the restaurant was a little more formal than I expected, and it is definitely not a place where I would feel comfortable wearing casual attire... more

The food is good-- just not as good as they think. more