I clearly should've tried a pie but instead got lured in by a peanut butter frosted cupcake. The cake was dried out and sort of stale tasting. Might have been saved by the frosting but that strangely had zero flavor. Disappointed but I guess that's what I get for getting cake at a place named after pie.

Walked by everyday for a year on my way to work. Often succumbed to the amazing aroma. Favorites are the banana cream pie and carrot cake. Key lime is also great. Took these pies to friends who always loved them.

Staying directly across the street, I felt a bit spoiled by this great little neighborhood pastry joint. Our host through Airbnb.com teased us with this cute and oh soo good lil apple pie and I couldn't just stop at one! It's our second evening staying here and I just had to have another! Tonight I went for the cheesecake. At... More

The lovely comforting smell of warm pies lure us in...we tried the signature apple pie one day and pecan pie the next. Both are delicious, with generous pieces of fruit/nut. Ask for the pie to be reheated if you are eating it in the cafe. But watch the microwave, our pecan pie was slightly overheated. Price is a little expensive... More

Two of us split a small (I would call it medium size) warm apple pie. Yummy. I think it is meant for 1 person, but was enough for the 2 of us, for a good sized decadent snack. We sat outside on the patio, relaxed, and ate pie. Excellent. Tasted home made to me. A bit expensive, but we thoroughly... More

What is best after a long day visiting NYC to stop for an apple pie and a cofee. Sited in a quiet street, near Times Square, this little shop is used by locals.

I loved the little apple pies :) and what about the cupcakes just the best thats what I got to say crazy good

Walking by we had a wonderful aroma meet us. After walking by on our way to the hotel a third time, we had to stop in for a slice of pie to share and were not disappointed. It was DELICIOUS! A wonderful find!

Everytime I pass by the smell just pulls me right into this place. Specially the pecan pie......I will die tomorrow happy if I had one piece. The place is small, but the pies are incredible. I love the little chairs right outside, it makes the place more cozy in this big city. so many pies, so little time!!!!!!!!!!!