We were a group of 4 that went last week without reservations. We were seated promptly and ordered ribeye, shrimp & chicken. Everything was excellent. The shrimp dish with mushrooms and a cream sauce was to die for, well, almost. No one had a complaint about this place. In fact, we wished we had stumbled upon it earlier on our... more

Single diner. 2 bottles of wine Burgess 1995 Cab @ $120 a bottle returned as undrinkable. This is a good wine. Not great, but good when served and stored correctly. Wine served warm. Stored warm according to the waitress. Turning to vinegar. Waitress spit wine out tasted from both glasses. Offered a taste to diners seated next to me. They... more

Hadn't booked but were able to take us quickly - Dad, Mum & 16 year old son. Restaurant packed up very quickly though. Great looking with loads of old historic pictures. Very noisy however and I think we were just unlucky as there was a drunk guy at the bar hitting on a young girl - but at the same... more

Nice place with interesting history. My steak was tougher than leather and so was the wife's chicken breast. Not very good. more

My husband and I stumbled across John's Grill walking around the Union Square area. We decided to reserve a table for dinner that evening. So glad we did for two reasons - firstly it became apparent shortly after we arrived that if we hadn't booked we would not have got a table - they were pouring in and the place... more

Do I dare admit that I ate a really good cheeseburger here once? more

O.k., so the place definitely does have a pecular oder which is noticable as soon as you walk in. After 5 minutes or so you forget about it. and was not an issue for us. My wife and I were very apprehensive about dining here due to several bad reviews. We were not seated in the large dining room but... more

decent fillet mignon more

What a great place, the atmosphere is great, a bit like a bar with food. There steaks are so great, so tender it melts on your tong, perfekt more