Husband and I stopped in for lunch here because it was close to our condo and we tend to like Italian food. We ordered a 12" pizza--had to pay $4 extra to have it "half & half." The house wine was $8/glass, and by the time my husband got a Coke, our lunch was $36. A little spendy for a... more

Wow, talk about a disappointment! We were recommended this restaurant at our resort and we went eagerly. Never again. 2 people ordered pizza and both were completely unremarkable. 2 people ordered pasta and they were good, but not great. The set up for ordering is chaotic, but once you get a seat things run smoothly. Wines are only average, and... more

My partner and I ate twice at this restaurant. On the first night we both had pasta and a bottle of wine. The pasta tasted like it was undercooked and overdone on the same plate and the wine (one we are familiar with) tasted watery. Service was mediocre and the place was crawling with screaming children which the manager did... more

This is a beautiful place to relax and enjoy a quiet meal...especially if you get there before 6. We ordered the Hawaiian Pizza and their Homemade Lasagna. A little disappointed that the Lasagna came with a side of grease in the bowl, but I just layed a piece of bread down to soaked it all up. It really did not... more

My wife and I went to Matteo's last month for dinner with our toddler and really liked the place. Pizza was pretty good and I loved the eggplant appetizer that we ordered. They're ordering system is a bit unique, but it was noce to find a casual dining option in Wailea that was so kid friendly. We ate out near... more

We stopped in in the afternoon to check this location out since it was so close to our hotel. It looked fabulous, great outdoor setting! Went in for dinner and wasn't impressed at all. The pizza crust was hard, toppings seemed less than fresh, it was just sort of subpar pizza, strange for such a nice setting. It was the... more

After reading reviews we were expecting really good itailian pizza/food but we ended up disappointed. The staff is friendly, prices are great (for Wailea), but the food....not so great. more

I recently visited Matteo's Pizzeria on a Friday night at 17.30 hrs. In short, I would recommend this place because, while the food is just average (not super great but also not bad), the prices are somewhat reasonable and the atmosphere is quite nice. I ordered a pizza and a salad. The pizza wasn't my favorite: if you like thin... more

Very average pizza. The service was poor and this place was pretty expensive for the low quality pizza they churn out. We will not be returning. more