Just had dinner there. The service was excellent and attentive. The food was delicious. The Baked Hawaii dessert was wonderful. The wine list and the prices, especially for Kauai were more than reasonable. Okay, so it is set in the midst of a condo complex it was still a great place to have dinner. We have eaten in many fancy... more

the most consistantly best food on Kauai. commonly overlooked because of their obscure location. great food, nice wine list, excellent service. more

My husband & I went there last night and not only was the food below average and overpriced, but the wait staff was completely unhelpful and even a bit strange. We asked for recommendations and they insisted everything was perfect. I asked for a meatless entree and the sauce was filled with meat! My husband ordered the garlic bread and... more

I can't understand all of the negative reviews of this fantastic restaurant! We stayed in Kauai for 6 days and Casa di Amici was so good we dined there twice! Unlike the two reviewers below, we had no trouble with the service. Our waiter was excellent, witty, and humorous, not to mention obligingly polite! The owner was constantly checking on... more

My wife and I along with another couple dined here while on vacation. We did make reservations for an early seating. The waiter seemed to take offense that only one person in our party ordered a glass of wine. We know this as my wife overheard him announce to the kitchen staff that he "had a cheap table" while she... more

We used to feel Cas Di Amici was a very well kept secret in Poipu. The first time we ate there, food and service were wonderful. Next time we went, food was fine but the ser vice was not good at all.Both times we had reservations. We found it odd that they charge you for their house bread! The next... more

We read many reviews and were expecting some good italian food. My meal was honestly discusting but edible. I was absolutely starving otherwise I would have never ate it. I ordered the eggplant. It was cooked, but bitter and the cheeses it was with did not mix or taste well together. It reminded me of something that I made when... more

Some of the raving, angry reviews on Trip-Advisor give me concerns. Fortunately, we ate here before I looked it up. We had a delightful dinner. We had dinner on March 14. I had their Paella. My wife had their Salmon. Both dishes were very attractive, creative, delicious, and even reasonable by Poipu standards. We spent $103 for a crab-cake appetizer,... more

We decided to go to Casa Di Amici after the hotel recommended it. We made reservations and were seated promptly. We found the menu to be leaning toward Italian but had dishes that had Mexican, Thai and Spanish leanings. My husband had the Saltembuca and I had the veal piccata. Both were very good. I really liked they had many... more