Took my husband to Eddie Martini's for his birthday. What a wonderful experience. Service was top notch, food was absolutely succulent. I had scallops, he had NY strip. Both were prepared to perfection. Wait staff is very attentive. Would highly recommend their bread pudding - it was sensational. I must say compared to other steak restaurants, Eddie Martini's was more... more

Outstanding service and excellent quality food. Fantastic martinis. Eddie's strives for a "fine dining experience". If that's what others call pretentious, so be it, but I am a frequent visitor and can state unequivocally that the staff puts effort into their service each and every day. I've always had a great meal and a great time. more

Just ate at Eddie Martini's restaurant, and the meal was a disappointment. The food was oversalted, a problem which could have been avoided. 3 out of a party of 4 felt similarly about the oversalted food. The management was less than sympathetic. I eat at many fine dining establishments in Milwaukee, and there are too many fine restaurants in this... more

Wonderful food and service. But the last time we paid $143.00 for 2. They are pricing themselves out of the Milwaukee market! more

Overall it's a wonderful experience, they certainly know how to make martinis, but I did feel as though the service was a little over the top. Especially for a city steeped in a culture of beer and brats. more

?!?! Pretentious? Overdone service? If you want to cook your own steak, go to the prime quarter! Eddie Martini's is THE preminent steak and seafood restaraunt in the Milwaukee area and the service is EXCELLENT. While many people enjoy its mouth-watering steaks or visually appealing "ocean martini" appetizers in formal attire, you are just as welcome in jeans. And THAT,... more

Best filet is the one on their special, not sure why it's always on the special, but its awesome. more

While yes, the food at Eddie's is absolutely delicious, the whole place is pretty pretentious. The service is nice and very proper, but they all could loosen-up a little bit! An experience there can get pretty pricey (>$100 for 2 people), especially at dinner if you drink alcohol-- so stick to lunch if you're on a lighter budget. I suggest... more

i have never had anything but great food at Eddie's. the service is, however, somewhat overdone. more