Our women's hiking group was well rewarded with a special dinner at the Mission Grille in Sister Bay, WI. After an afternoon hike at Cave Point County Park our group of 12 ladies enjoyed a delicious dinner. I ordered from their prix fixe menu and chose; Apple-Goat cheese salad with dried cherries, candied pecans and goat Chevre cheese, as an... More

Although pricey, I had a filet. It was cooked perfectly and was so tasty. We had a party of four and all of us really enjoyed our dinning experience. The others in my party had Duck, scallops and prime rib. Salads are small. Great wine list!

Our servers Nikki (and trainee also named Nikki) were fantastic! My special request of switching sauces on the salmon (not a cilantro fan) was carried out without a hitch. My husband's Duo of Pork entree with the rhubarb chutney and mashed sweet potatoes was to die for! My Lobster Bisque and Wild Salmon dinner were both excellent and the Cherry-Walnut... More

Routine visit to Door County with family and a friend. Started at Sturgeon Bay Fine Art Fair & then traveled up the Pennisula to Sister Bay. We decided to try the Mission Grille for lunch. We were seated in the front window area facing the road. Upon our travels to the restroom we checked out the main restaurant decor, which... More

My wife and I spent our anniversary in Door County and wanted to celebrate with a special dinner. After reading reviews on other sites, my wife picked mission grille. Overestimating our drive time from Sturgeon Bay, we arrived about 20 minutes early. The hostess informed us that even though it was a Saturday night, it was no problem and she... More

I wrote a really glowing review the other day but didn't submit it right so let me try again. We were here last week twice and had a great time. Once with regular entrees and the second time with a series of appetizers/small plates. Everything was delicious (Margarita's are scrumptious) and are wait servers and the hostess were delightful. Love... More

I think my original review came off as snotty, so I wanted to revise it. The food was good, just heavier than I was expecting. I would definitely come back here for a lighter lunch, and sit in the windowed front area for a change of view.

Mission Grille was our second choice but we are certainly glad our first choice was closed that weekend. Everything here was perfect. The restaurant itself is lovely and beautifully decorated especially during the holidays. Our server, (I wish I could remember her name because it was unique) was very friendly and attentive. She told us about the menu options and... More

Decided to eat here because this restaurant used to be a catholic church and was curious on what we would find. We ate lunch here because the dinner menu was a little more expensive than lunch. They had an excellent menu and it was hard to choose what to eat. The restaurant is very beautiful inside. Enjoyed our meal. Would... More