The lobby area of this wonderfully decorated hotel is also a lounge area. It is extremely comfortable and is a great venue for people watching. The art works by Charles Dwyer are most intriguing. The service has always been great. The servers are most friendly and helpful. Kudos goes to our most recent server, Andy Holm. He had great wine... more

I have had 3 different visits to Smyth Restaurant in the Iron Horse Hotel. Each one was a 10 in my book and I'm not easy to please. My waitress has always been Dawn and I really like her because she is so down to earth. She never smothers us but always seems to be there when we need something.... more

Our family celebrated this past Thanksgiving weekend by dining at the Smyth restaurant in the Iron Horse hotel on two separate nights, and we were amazed at the décor, the service, the warmth from all personnel who waited on us and the awesome food. Entering the Iron Horse is an experience in itself with the warm lighting, fantastic music and... more

THIS WAS AMAZING. Lisa was an unbelievable waitress. We will request her next time. I feel like we received special treatment. Every bit of food we tasted was spectacular. the Veal, the Venison, the carrot soup, the beer soup..... THE CHEESE PLATE with the honey rosemary dipping sauce..AMAZING!! The atmosphere was so lovely and this will be a truly memorable... more

Thanks to Lisa for being a really excellent server last weekend! Despite being busy, she really took the time to make our night special, and had the kind of charisma that puts a server over the top. I'd like to say the we could also tell the restaurant is well-managed, so apparent by the way the staff worked as a... more

A New York type restaurant in the hinterlands. Geared for Carnivores. Top flight wine list,. more

This was my first dining experience at Smyth inside The Iron Horse Hotel. The place was very pretty with the cream city brick and wood design. Lisa, our waitress, was polite and friendly. The best part of the evening was seeing Tom Schultz, the head chef. He came to our table and answered questions that we had about the menu.... more

On the night we visited in August, Rachel was are server. She was well informed as to what was available and made great suggestions. Her attention to service was the best we have ever had anywhere. If you get a chance to eat at the Iron Horse, request Rachel, you will not regret it. more

We were a group of 8. Our food arrived cold and was over cooked. Service was slow and the server was incompetent. Atmosphere was great. Nice place. Comfortable. Noise level is HIGH!!!! There are so many GOOD restaurants in Milwaukee area - this isn't one of them. The place was mobbed... we didn't get it. We won't return. more