This tourist cafe was amazing - particularly for a historic site that caters to a lot of kits. It was not your usual hot dogs and soda. We had really delicious brunswick stew and bread pudding with a wonderful fruit sauce. The salad was also good. I just found the stew recipe online and am going to try to make... More

The Jamestown Settlement Café is right on the property at the Jamestown Settlement area. It shares a lobby with the ticket area and so it is very convenient for a lunch break when touring Jamestown. Being a café at a tourist site, you would expect the prices to be relatively high and they were right up there. The food itself... More

Surprising number of options for a lunch while touring the Settlement. Good seating, well planned.

Burgers, salads, hot dogs, etc., Large cafeteria style restaurant.

This was hands down the worst cafe I have ever been to, that includes hospital cafes. First off it is not a cafe at all, it is a cafeteria, you stand in line with a tray to get over priced and under heated food. I grabbed a pre made plain Jell-o (at a cost $3.50!) because I figured it would... More

Food was ok, but ridiculously expensive. For 4 adults to eat it came to almost $60 and we barely had anything. They charged $2 for a carton of milk - who does that? Very disappointed in the overall dining experience, especially since it is a family attraction.

Summary: Not Recommended. Go somewhere else and have a better lunch, for less. Food quality is poor. Bill: expensive. Couldn’t get cheese pizza right. Only positive is its easy location: In the Jamestown Settlement Visitor’s Center, so its very simple to just stay there and eat and continue with you touring. The Cafe has a nice setting and very ample... More

Just had to write a short note - I have been making bread pudding for over 35 years from the same New Orleans recipe - and always claim to make the best, but the bread pudding my husband and I shared (there was plenty!) was the most delicious I have ever tasted!

Jamestown Settlement takes advantage of a somewhat captive audience by jacking up the prices at their in-house restaurant. It doesn't help that prices aren't marked on many items. I said "REALLY?!" out loud when the cashier told us our total. It may be a pain to head out elsewhere for lunch, but you should do it anyway.