Eat or drink here most days when I'm in Middlebury. Service is excellent. The bread, sandwiches, speciality salads and pastries are wonderful.
Was visiting Middlebury for the first time and came across the Otter Creek Bakery. Had amazing sandwiches and very creative specials. Cozy atmosphere and central location.
We stopped in for coffee and pastries on a Saturday morning. Best fresh bread smells ever, unbelievably flaky tender croissants, outstanding blueberry muffin and the honey cornbread scone probably topped them all. Only minor let down was the cafe latte (too much foam). Great friendly local bakery.
The sandwich, which we climbed over 25 other people to get, was really good, and the take out mini apple pie was quite a fresh-tasting treat. Just a crazy place to try to get into - a bit chaotic as to who's ordering, waiting, hanging out! We were able to eat outside in the lovely, California-style lanai area on a... More
We stopped by this little bakery spot last April while visiting Middlebury College with our son. We were told how wonderful the food was. We found the pastries to be average and both employees we encountered to be quite unfriendly. Will try a new spot next time we are in town.
I love this place and I've yet to visit another bakery in Vermont that can compete. The Maple Danishes rock. Lunch is great here too. You can’t go wrong with signature sandwiches like the Otter Creek sub. Everything is always served fresh by a friendly and courteous staff, especially the tall red head that makes a mean espresso.
Took my three kids down to the bakery for lunch on a Saturday, it was packed. Had the Mid-wester, it was very good. The bread is as it should be, nearly European in its quality. A bit costly, but it's what you'd expect for locally grown fare...and I was happy to pay the premium for the fresh food!
This place is yummy and wonderful! You should grab a coffee and dessert and enjoy!!! Artful and earthy baked goods to delight!
They have the best sandwiches and pastries in Vermont. They have great service and amazing food. I would love to come here again. I promise you won't find anything better than otter bakery!
If you own or manage Otter Creek Bakery, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing