Great pizza, Italian style, friends come from the Cape and this is what they want for dinner. Nuff said.
We read mixed reviews about this place on different web sites but decided to give it a try looking to get a pizza to take back to Jackson Gore Inn. When you first walk in at seems a little dark and the atmosphere is a little stark. We ordered a large pizza with sausage, mushrooms and peppers. It only took... More
We recently took out several pies for an after skiing dinner at the condo. Everyone was blown away by how good the pizza was. My son-in-law is a NYC pizza snob and even he was impressed. Don't leave Ludlow without trying Goodman's. You'll be making a big mistake. Great sauce, thin crust, just the right amount of cheese and cooked... More
We really enjoyed the delicious pizzas at Goodmans. The pizzas were enormous (had to do 'carry out' as we couldn't manage it all in one go), and had that authentic wood-fired oven taste. The bases were tasty - good texture, and piled high with toppings. Lots of fun features in the quirky joint - we loved eating sitting in an... More
This is really good pizza and their special pizzas are great. The rip curl was yummy (pesto, ricotta, chicken, tomatoes and mozzarella) and you can create your own pizza with a choice of five sauces and numerous toppings. When we went, the phone was constantly ringing with orders. As the owner likes to keep the oven at a constant temperature,... More
This was awesome pizza. Being from NYC the stakes are high but this was definitely one of the best pizzas I have had in a while. The place has lots of charm and character, with a VW van refurbished and used as the counter in front of the owner's homemade wood burning stove,
American Pie has fantastic wood-fired pizza that would stand up to any Tri-state pizza. The topping choices are creative and upscale. The only issue is the time it takes to get the food. We're they to pick up the pace the rating would be excellent.
Great pizza with good high quality pizza. Loved the vibe with the skiing/hippy decor. Seemed to have fairly limited seating so may be tricky when its busy.
If you own or manage Goodman's American Pie, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing