Good wine selection including some wineries I have visited when in Tuscany. Salads were good, not great. Pasta dishes were good, but no better than Carrabba's. Main courses (meat and fish) were bland...no flavor at all. Didn't bother to try desserts. Restaurant is very noisy and one table was exceptionally loud and obnoxious..obviously way too much to drink. Unfortunately, the... More

My wife and I are frequent visitors to HHI and this year, we decided to try Michael Anthoney's for the first time...and we went back. The first trip was for a Monday night dinner. We loved the atmosphere, the service , the food and the wine. At dinner, we learned that they also had cooking schools during the week...and before... More

My significant other called, found restaurant and got me a gift certificate for my birthday. Restaurant management took the time to mail it to her so she could surprise me. Ambience, food and service were all excellent. Tremendous wine selection at decent prices. One of my favorite Italian restaurants, we are going back!

My husband & I enjoyed a lovely dinner at Michael Anthony's. It is one of our favorites on HHI. We have dined there several times and the meal and service are always excellent. Our most recent waiter was waiter Finnie, and we were in very good hands that evening.

After being turned away by "Vine," the staff at Michael Anthony's gave us a warm Southern welcome. Our kids weren't thrilled by the haute Italian cuisine, but the chef happily created some off-menu items, which proved to be big hits. The pasta dishes were bursting with flavor and freshness. And the staff -- from maitre'd to bus boy to server... More

Great cooking and wine events. And... A wonderful Italian restaurant . The deli style back room grocery/ speciality show is a nice bonus too.

Fantastic atmosphere, excellent food and a great staff. This place is on the list I recommend to everyone.

We went here after a recommendation from our friends. This ways by far the best Italian restaurant we have ever been to and the best restaurant we have eaten at on the Island. The food was incredible, the staff was extremely friendly and helpful, and the atmosphere was upscale. We are definitely telling all our friends about Michael Anthony's and... More

Have had so many recommendations to try this restaurant we expected much better. I really want to give an even lower rating, but feel like our experience was mostly just a combination of circumstances that could be easily corrected by management tweaking a few things. Having said that, there are so many good restaurants on Hilton Head we won't waste... More