We decided to splurge and go all out at this restaurant. Started with delicious sushi, the Rockin Roll. Not being a raw fan I was glad to see all the cooked sushi choices. Had good, potent drinks. I had the scallops and my wife had the grilled salmon. Both dishes were very good. Took home dessert - Tarimasu and raspberry... more

service had a fake feeling to it just there for the tip it seemed like.my wife asked about the soy crusted snapper,and was told it was a breadcrumb crust,so why did it say soy crust? she ordered it and it had no breadcrumbs and little if any soy.the rice with crab essence was good but fish was dry and overcooked.they... more

This sophisticated restaurant has the best atmosphere on the island. I would suggest you make a reservation for dinner but show up during happy hour first for a few drinks and sushi appetizers at the bar with Woody (the bartender). He took very good care of us with half off drinks and sushi for happy hour. I think that's every... more

You will get all 3 at the Alligator Grille ! The Alligator Grille is a great spot on the island for chic upscale dining. From the funky alligator and eclectic artwork to the raised cozy dining areas, the Alligator Grille invites you into a GREAT dining experience. Owner Regan Barnum has assembled a friendly, talented staff to serve you. Woody... more

The Alligator Grill was a happy surprise. We have been vacationing in Sea Pines for 25 years and this year was the first year we have eaten in the Alligator Grill. Four of us had different dishes and found them delicious. The wait staff was attentive to every detail of the meal. We were so pleased we went back for... more

My family dined at the Alligator Grille 2 nights ago and were underwhelmed with our dining experience. I had the alligator gumbo for the novelty of having alligator (which I knew tasted pretty much like chicken), but the gumbo was pretty bland overall. My husband had the spider rolls (fried soft shelled crab) and the eel roll. My husband really... more

Luis at the sushi bar hosts a sushi cooking class that is excellent - he is personable, informed and skilled in his task. We received many superb tips for making sushi and had the opportunity to construct a roll that we then ate. The menu is also excellent and everything is made right at the bar. The tempura teriyaki roll... more

Recently dined here! Service was great! The young man making the sushi gave us a sample on the house (whole Roll) Which was out of this world!! Also made us a dessert roll (again, on the house) which my fiance raved about! I didn't indulge :0)! more

I don't trust recommendations written in superlatives, but it would be difficult to write about Hilton Head Island's Alligator Grille without using them--a lot of them. The menu, the wine list, the food, the service, the decor, and the ambience are all outstanding and worth putting on the "must return to" list we Hilton Head vacationers keep. I knew from... more