Very friendly staff. Great selection of sandwiches and plenty of choices for dessert! Lots of flavors of ice cream, and specials each day. We love to visit on Tuesday! Slow roasted beef on kaiser rolls. It's out of this world!!!!

Very friendly staff. Great selection of sandwiches and plenty of choices for dessert! Lots of flavors of ice cream, and specials each day. We love to visit on Tuesday! Slow roasted beef on kaiser rolls. It's out of this world!!!!
Great Ice cream, better than average food. A small establishment right on Main street. great place to stop in on those warm summer nights after a long day touring Amish country. You can miss this gem if you are not paying attention.
If you are looking for a fun and inviting place to try something new, this is the place you need to visit. The menu has both traditional choices and some unique sandwich selections combining ingredients you would not normally see. However, they melt in your mouth and are delicious. The dessert choices are endless and presented in a fun and...
More
I love their sandwich selections. Some have different ingredients that I wouldn't have thought of but are delicious. Great home made soups. The ice cream selection is also very good. I visit regularly for lunch.
This is a very good place to go for sandwiches and ice cream. Ice cream in a cone or dish or sundaes are really good. Nice little cozy busness, family owned and located in the little town of New Holland.
Lickity Split has been my favorite ice cream place for almost 10 years! You can buy what they call a "2 Scoop." A "2 Scoop" in a regular person's mind would be...well...2 scoops! Well, here, you NEVER get ripped off for money! Here, you order a "2 Scoop" and they would give you 4...(!) scoops of ice cream! This is,...
More
This place is a cute storefront in downtown New Holland. It is quaint inside, offering lots of choices for ice cream and sandwiches. Nice place to stop with the family during warm summer months.
Always a good choice for a sandwich and some ice cream. So many different sandwich choices!
Cute little ice cream parlor right on Route 23 in New Holland. My husband and I had dinner and stopped in here for dessert. There are many ice cream flavors to choose from as well as shakes or sundaes. The servers are attentive and friendly.
I enjoy the bright colors and atmosphere in this aged building. It's a wonderful crossroads of mixing the old with the new. I have had the Garden Spot Melt and the Baler Beef Melt. I really enjoy both, enough that it's hard for me to try other sandwiches I like both so much.
It's a really fun place to go...
More
If you own or manage Lickity Split, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing