We had great sandwiches that were served quickly. I had a Philly-steak and it was great. Open air atmosphere makes for a great island experience.

This should be an automatic stop for you if you are walking into town! The prices are great and the beer is cold! They have live entertainment in the afternoon and a great porch to enjoy it on! The food is really great "bar food" and again, great prices!

Easy ordering, great bar food, cool atmosphere, medium prices. The only thing I didnt like, was their jukebox was turned up way to loud.

Aervice was a little lack luster an portion size was less than average for the price . Beer was a little pricey as well

My family (husband and two kids 16 yrs and 13 yrs) visited Put In Bay on 06/14/12. We went to Tony's Garage for lunch and was so happy we did! Great food and fun atmosphere. The "garage" has big roll up doors and the breeze was blowing and it was a perfect day (well, us Florida natives were a bit... More

After all the seafood, had a taste for a great burger. This was the place!

Tony's was a good choice for larger groups becasue the food is ordered at a walk-up window and checks/payments are all individual (no hassle over splitting up a check). The bar had a nice selection of specials which were all decenlty priced. The burgers, wings and chili cheeses fries were all good choices.

Wow, how can the quality of food change so much in a year? This has. Total disappointment for 2012. Save your money and eat elsewhere! Tried to tell management so they can fix, but we were completely ignored. Too bad, hopefully the owners will realize their mistake. The good thing this place has is Reese Dailey Band! They are excellent... More

The service here was not good, the blonde waitress seemed like she was in a hurry and did NOT want to be there. The food was just ok, I wouldn't go back. The sauce they use for dipping was good though. I feel like something is fishy about this being number one at the bay especially because I have been... More