this place makes a killer Shepherds Pie, and the Irish nachos are pretty tasty, too. An excellent selection of Irish beers and whisky.
We took a day trip it Put in Bay just knock around and we stop in for lunch. Service was great and the food was excellent. I highly recommend that if your on the island you stop in and get a pint or two and a bit.
The service was great, The food was excellent, and the prices were ok also. There were not very busy, so we were seated and waited on in no time. The food was very good. They attended our table often. The bar is very big and was nice.
Great Service, Great food! We always visit her first on our yearly trips to the bay! The portion size is generous, the food is always tasty and piping hot, and the service is always spirited and prompt! They also have amazing nightly dinner specials and the best fish and chips I have ever had on this side of the pond!... More
It's a bar with Irish food. What could be wrong? We especially liked their Irish nachos, and friendly service.
There was a nice selection of beer. You can get a paddle (4 different beers) for $8. The bartender seemed friendly but busy because she also waited on tables too. Prices were pretty good on beers.
I can say that was the best restaurant at Put in Bay. Nice value of foods, tasty fish&chips, tasty beers. Nice Irish pub. We were very disappointed when we saw that they close the kitchen at 9 PM, i think that's because after Labor Day the season is over at the island.
Went to Hooligans based on a recommendation from a friend and was not disappointed. They had a decent selection of beer, beyond the Bud Lite that seemed to be prevalent at most of the other bars on the island. It was overpriced but that seems to be the norm for Put-In-Bay. There were some Irish specialties on the menu but... More
This restaurant was fine. The negative was our slow waitress. She did not visit our table very often. I ran out of water half way through my meal, and never got a refill. We finished our meals and waited 5-10 minutes for her to bring our check. Then waited again for her to return for the money. The food itself... More
Try the Reuben Sandwich and soup. Denny is the best server and it is nice to sit on the porch and eat. Stop in and enjoy some beer at the large bar; often there is Irish music for listening.
If you own or manage Hooligans, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing