Do not waste even a penny on the chocolate covered bacon. Yech ! Folks were not friendly. We won't go back there.
Never can go to PIB without stopping here. We always find something iyummy eat! We got a chocolate covered peanut butter oreo, a chocolate covered butter nutter cookie, a rice krispie treat, a dark chocolate coconut stack, and a chocolate covered caramel goody. All very good and very fresh!
Here is your chance to get odd candy and type you can't find anywhere else. Be prepared to pay for it! The fudge is not all that good but everything else is great. Did I mention you will pay for the novelty and it is very hard to say no to the kids... Close at 10.
Perfect little spot after lunch and shopping on the island. The fudge is delish! especially the peanut butter fudge. Only wish they had cute touristy boxes of candy with "Put-In-Bay" on it to bring back home to NY.
Stopped here on a recent visit, nice selection of candies you won't see in a lot of places. We had just eaten lunch so didn't buy any candy, but opted for the ice cream in back. It was very good but very expensive $3.25/scoop.
I absolutely loved the white chocolate oreo bark bar that I got - it made the Hersey's oreo bars pale in comparison! The selection of candy and sweets was amazing, and I'm sure this place drives kids insane with desire! I do have to say, it was kind of an unwelcoming atmosphere though. I think something was going on because... More
I always stop at the candy store while I am on the island. They have a large selection of novelty candy and last year I had the opportunity to use a cotton candy making machine they have. This place is a little pricey, but it is worth the money. I do not personally buy the fudge, but they have a... More
All the old time favorite candy is available as well as great chocolate items. A must stop on any trip to PIB!
Thank you for taking the time to review our store. We try very hard to make all our customers feel like "a kid in a candy store." We appreciate your business! More
If you own or manage The Candy Store, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing