I've been getting pizzas at Mary's for over 40 years. Mary's has always made the best pizza you can find.
Best pizza in the area. Be prepared for a VERY heavy pizza, but that is it's beauty. There are a ton of topping, especially cheese. SOOO tasty. WIll return again and again.
Had large "The Everything" pizza while passing through lisbon. Holy moly that was one of the best pizzas ive had in recent memory. Dough is crispy and delicious. Super good when cold. Customer service was great and chatty. Thanks for the tip fellow posters.
Mary's pizza is the most amazing pizza in columbiana county...the portions you get are amazing.. The flavor is exceptional....Good job Mary's Pizza
Their pizzas are beautiful deep-dish pizzas with toppings laid on thick! I am not a fan of the meat sauce that comes on the pizza, it is a little too sweet for me. But, I absolutely love their whole tomato sauce! The Italian Wedding Soup is divine, pepperoni rolls are huge and their steak or chicken salads are always fresh... More
This is the absolute best pizza we've ever had if you like thick pizza. We have to drive 30min one way so we only get it on special nights. The sauce is a more sweet sauce and there is tons of cheese. You can get it cooked. frozen or bake it at home with a baggie of cheese to put... More
The pepperoni rolls are great and they are BIG. Salads and Pizzas are wonderfull too. You must take a visit to Lisbon and visit Mary's Pizza shop, you won't regret it.
Grew up eat this best pizza ever! Love the homemade thick crust and the sauce is to die for! The pepperoni rolls are great too. The best of homemade everything. The garlic wings are good too!
I like it a lot. It is a meal in it self. The pizza is so thick with sauce and cheese! Not in eat in kind of place, but great pizza. Wins many awards locally and always good to support local business.
If you own or manage Mary's Pizza Shop, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing