great pie more

This place is awesome. Great food and great beer selection at a reasonable price. I found it to be especially CLEAN. I heard they have a new manager there, but otherwise can't figure out why those other reviews exist. I have heard of former employees being disgruntled....don't know. The pesto sauce is my fav. I would avoid the meatloaf....leave that... more

Good music and beer selection but they have a rodent problem at both their locations more

Freaking great more

Just kind of standard fare. more

My family and I ate there last week and in the corner next to our table was rat feces. Needless to say we will never eat there again. more

We love Fat Tony's! We ate here for the first time a couple of years ago after it was recommended to us by a local police officer. (They always know the best places!) We loved it and make it a point to go each time we visit the area (about 2X a year). Good value & GREAT food!! more

You gotta see this place. It's like a castle inside. The food was awesome. I had lasagna and my wife had chicken Marsala and they were the best we have ever had. The bartender Scott had us laughing our a$$@$ off. We went and had a drink on the patio and watched the boats go by on the Cape Fear... more

After eating here with a group of friends, our debit card was double charged to the tune of about $180! After confronting the owners several times, they finally credited back the error, but in the meantime, this overcharge led to several other items bouncing. The owners lied to me, saying that they would reimburse me, but first wanted to talk... more