The food is fresh and delicious, the staff are knowledgeable warm and welcoming. We will always keep coming back!
After a day in the nature reserve, we enjoyed a delicious meal here. I ordered seafood ravioli and my boyfriend ordered a fish dish that I can't recall the name of but it was mouth watering. We indulged each and every bite. Can't wait to go back!
Arrived on Shelter Island after a long, tiring trip. We were freezing and hungry, feeling like refugees. Jimmy seated us by the fire, and we had a perfect meal. Balm to the soul and senses. Highly recommend!
I visited last weekend, there were six of us for lunch. We were greeted promptly and given a very nice table we all ordered a Bloody Mary which was very good and came within minutes. The room was very nice not overly decorated and spotless. My only complaint would be that there could have been a little more on the... More
I took a party of 13 here last weekend on the Sunday after my son's wedding. The food and service was excellent, which isn't always the case for a large party. The menu is interesting and a few in our group had the the Steak Florentine( Huge portion) which they raved about. I had the daily special< Ciopino, Lobster, clams,... More
We came across this restaurant simply due to the fact is was very close to our hotel. We were pleasantly surprised with the amazing service, well presented specials, and the quality of food. Not to mention the nice touch of having the owner not only meet and greet, but genuinely take an interest in all his guests. We went here... More
Great place on a hot Labor Day wknd to sit inside this lovely restaurant. Nothing like the pix of the outside. Great pizzas, rose, and service. We sat at a beautiful bay window. Nicki our server couldn't have been nicer. Hope she's there when we return. All wait staff are friendly and all the guests were having a lovely meal... More
This was our second dining experience at the restaurant, which is very conveniently located a short walk from Dering Cove Harbor. The surroundings are pleasant, with a choice of inside or outside dining. We ended up at the bar and ordered from that menu, although the dining room menu, with some entrees offered in regular and smaller sized portions, was... More
If you own or manage Sweet Tomato's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing