I love to go here and the service is always excellent. The food is fantastic being homemade! Love this place!
Three weeks ago My wife & I went there for breakfast. It was fantastic. I had eggs up over easy, bacon, rye toast. Plus it came with potatoes with roasted red & green peppers. It made the potatoes extra tasty. My wife had strawberry waffle, She enjoyed it alot. Now lets not forget about the our waitress, She was super.... More
We came here to use up a gift card we had sitting around. It had been a few years since we last ate here and the place was just as good as I remember it being. We both ordered soft drinks and I had the Haddock Florentine while my dining partner had the soup and salad. The food was very... More
We were staying in Clinton for the night and traveled to New Hartford for dinner. My brother suggested this cafe to us. We were more than pleased with everything. Our server, Michael, was wonderful.
Had been to Carmella's a few years back, then we moved away. Now we're back in the area and are blown away by their food, service, and value. All of the items that we tried were unique recipes that seemed to be perfected by the staff. The atmosphere was welcoming, and it was very well priced. Our Friday night meal... More
Every time my boyfriend and I drive past Carmella's I want to eat there again. Our first time was for lunch on a Saturday afternoon and we were seated right away. Our waitress was polite and attentive to our needs and as the title says, the food was great! We shared an appetizer of loaded fries and they're better than... More
This was my first visit to Carmella's Cafe and it was outstanding. All their pasta, bread, and sauces are homemade. I tried the Chicken Riggies, and it was far better than other places. The sauce was excellent, and combined with the seasoned chicken, it was very flavorful. My wife had the California Pasta and was impressed with all the fresh... More
Now I know why there were so many cars in the parking lot on a holiday in the summer. Food was awesome, bread was served hot and the salad was good. We were happy that we ate here instead of Ponderosa. Will go back next time we visit friends in Utica!
Great place for the whole family. I love their onions rings they are so crunchy. Another one of my favorites is the fish 'n' chips beer battered haddock fish. My husband loves their chicken riggies and their certified steaks.
If you own or manage Carmella's Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing