Whenever we visited Montauk, this was a must stop for us. The service and quality have always been great and consistent.

We always start of our weekend Montauk day adventure with a hearty breakfast from this place. Tried several of their omeletes , dishes and pancakes and always live satisfied. Most of the time we get the friendly service sometimes we have to wave our hands for attention , the place does feel that time stood still but this and the... More

We waited about 30 minutes to eat here on a rainy day. The menu is very broad and we enjoyed our meal. Don't expect a gourmet dining experience, but for a standard breakfast diner menu this place gets it done and does it well.

An old fashioned diner style breakfast restaurant with good service and good food. Much more pleasant, in terms of ambiance, than the overcrowded and apparently more frequented John's Pancake House across the street. All the dishes we ordered were made with simple, fresh ingredients. Good coffee.

This place was awful. They were understaffed which is understandable because it was 1pm on new years eve, however the place was practically empty. I went with my girlfriend and they got both our orders wrong. They charged my girlfriend extra for mushrooms in her omelette which she did not receive. I ordered home fries and was given corned beef... More

This is the alternative to the stupidity across the street. No reason to wait an hour to eat breakfast. The pancakes and waffles here are just as good and they have more seating.

I think it is 1-2 between them and their neighbor across the street. Good service , quality food. Montauk is a breakfast town as most motels do not serve so...better be good...alot of competition. And Anthony's is very good.

Easy to get to - nice to enjoy breakfast downtown. Nice atmosphere and menu......well worth the visit, to eat, relax and enjoy the location.

For the money I would have expected more than just a stack of plain pancakes that tasted Ok, but this is Montauk and everything is $$$