This place always comes highly recommended, so we keep trying it, but have yet to have the experience we are promised by friends. Just unremarkable in many ways. Staff is not terribly friendly, menu isn't great, and food is over-rated bar food. Everything I have had here was disappointing, pasta, mussels, ribs, pizza, etc. I would recommend sitting outside with... More

Each dish, meant for sharing, was a surprising treat--attractive to look at and exceptionally tasty. The waitstaff generously directed us toward the proper choices for our evening meal. Make a reservation if there on the weekend, although sitting at the bar or cafe table is swell.

We just loved everything about this restaurant. We went back 2 nights in a row. The food, staff and ambience is perfect. Reservations are required long in advance during the summer season. I would suggest making the reservation before you begin your travels. Its that good. Waterfront on Fort Pond, amazing place for a sunset.

The food was excellent with huge portions. Everyhting is served family style which allows you to sample all of their best dishes. We had a group of 12, ordered 2 salads, 1 pizza and three entrees and it was more than enough food for everyone to get a taste of everything. They also have a wonderful selection of wine on... More

We've been eating at Harvest since it opened, and have not had a bad meal. Occasionally we get an indifferent server. The seafood bruschetta is top notch, as is the pork tenderloin with the apple apricot chutney, which we just discovered last July. The pasta dishes are also good. I did note that this year the bruschetta had a few... More

We visited in March, the food was great, enormous portions and fantastic champagne. The waitress was Australian,a really helpful person . For me just a main world have been enough although all was well presented.

Their signature octopus salad was delicious. Rack of lamb had excellent flavor, but not nearly as tender as expected. My companion had skirt steak, which he said was "good, but not memorable." Beautiful restaurant, good service. I liked the vibe and would definitely try it again.

One of the top restaurants in Montauk. Always packed because of the overlarge portions of great food on the menu. The noise is nonstop and without a reservation you could easily wait a few hours. Is it worth it? If you have the patience, the food is fun, great and enjoyable.

The food , the service, the atmosphere, all second to none. The calamari salad and the steak are must haves. The chef always has some wonderful specials on offer also