Ate here twice while visiting for several days in Ithaca. I was really taken with the place. I love a good bakery and the bakery items, especially the bread look wonderful. There are so many other things to eat here, which is what makes the place so great. A number of sandwich options to choose from plus a great salad/food... more

I recently ate at Ithaca Bakery with my 17 year-old son while on a college visit to Cornell. We had heard good things about the restaurant but were somewhat disappointed. We used to live in Ann Arbor, MI and they have a place similar this but so exceeds it, Zingerman's. The menu looks very intriguing, with tons of sandwich combinations... more

I've eaten here a number of times... and they only get my order right about 50% of the time. It's rather frustrating. However, on the occasions that they get my order right, their food isn't bad- although, I feel that they are a bit overpriced for the ultimate product. Their delivery isn't that great- my order usually arrives soggy. I'm... more

Well deserved reputation for good food, quick and very friendly service, and great value. Not just a bakery -- sandwiches, soups, meal deals, breakfast, gourmet items. more

We happened upon Ithaca bakery after church on Sunday after the Mardi Gras wine weekend at Cayuga Lake. I was lucky enough to be there on teacher's week because we were able to use a buy 1/get 1 free coupon on "specialty sandwiches". Well if we have the opportunity again, with or without coupon-this sandwich is the "BOMB". Melt in... more

Favorite sandwich shop in town. more

Overpriced! Huge selection of interesting [small!] sandwiches. more

This is a great place for bagels, sandwiches, cookies, breads, and other assorted baked goods. I love to stop by here for a treat once in a while. more

Great sandwiches and sides, although rather slow... more