Even though its well known as the "best" steakhouse in NY, and it was really good, I would say I've had better. The porterhouse to share is the way to go, and while really tasty, its overcome with the au jus that it kinda detracts from the taste of the meat itself. still an overall great steak experience, but just... more

This is a popular restaurant and you need to reserve Saturday nights two months in advance. With a young family, it's a treat to be able to go out for a birthday dinner and my wife booked a dinner for the two of us, booking a long while back. Unfortunately, during the reservation confirmation the day before, they were confirming... more

Must order Steak-for-two medium rare, otherwise, no good. more

I heard about Peter Luger's from Oprah's best burger list. The burger was by far the best tasting burger human kind has ever produced. Worth the trip but don't forget to make a reservation, you might be turned away. more

I dont consider spending $600.00 for 6 people a bargain for what I ate. I shared a salad with my son and my wife because it was big enough for all 3 of us. I shared an onion and a tomato uncooked as an apetizer, which made no sense at all. The vegatable of choice was creamed spinach and brocoli... more

I have eaten at Peter Luger many times, and I have never been disappointed. The appetizers are not to be overlooked, and the martinis are perfect. The main feature is, of course, the steak - always cooked to perfection. (Skip the sauce, though - it's too sweet.) The only down side is that they only accept cash or their own... more

You are better off at Morton's, Maxwell and Dunnes, or Tellers more

Huge portion. more

Cannot say enough great things. I have been fortunate to eat some of the finest steaks several times a week and this experience topped it all. Seeing that this was my first trip to Brooklyn I decided to take no short cuts. Appetizers were wonderful. Bacon was like no other I have tasted. Side dishes were flawless and then of... more