We were very unhappy with the way our evening turned out. Our waitress was incredibly inattentive and borderline rude, our meals were horrible, etc. We got our $9.00 BASKET OF CHIPS appetizer AFTER we were done with our entrees and we still had to pay for it. Our meat was INCREDIBLY under cooked, and the sides with the meals were... More

Wanted a nice dinner with our daughter who is a student at nearby HWS but we were a bit disappointed with our meals. My salmon was very dry although my husband's steak was nicely cooked. Might be that we ordered the wrong meal, but for the price, we would have expected more consistency. Service was lovely so we might need... More

This is the second time this year I've been to the Cobblestone. The first was with another couple and the second time was with 10 people. While the food was excellent both times, the waitress during the first visit was cold and aloof, having to be called to attend to us. The second waitress was very attentive and served the... More

i had dinner at the cobblestone last week and i just wanted to say how much i enjoyed it. The atmosphere,The service,The food--everything was exceptional. I had the chilean sea bass hard to find in western New York and it was as good as i've had anywhere.dessert was chocolate souffl'e; for a chocoholic its amazing A GREAT TIME

We recently had a wonderful experience at Cobblestone. When we walked into the restaurant we were greeted at the door by Kristy who was very welcoming. She showed us to our table which was next to the fireplace...very warm and romantic. The restaurant was quiet but that is typical this time of year. Tammy was our server and she was... More

Nice ambience but don't go for the food or value. It was recommended by our hotel clerk and I wonder if it was once top notch and now has a different chef? My husband and I were there for Valentine's Day and maybe only 25% of the tables were occupied and both the bartender and our waiter were working there... More

I was impressed by the offerings on the menu, but not at all happy with the food. We started with Lobster "escargot". The butter sauce was flavorless and an odd thickness. The oysters were breaded well, but the dipping sauce was bland. The salads were uninspired, but crisp and clean. No bad lettuce pieces as happens more than it should.... More

Cobblestone is one of the most stunning buildings in Geneva. You feel as if you are dining in an old estate. I love the interior. Dining outside is possible - but the busy intersection is a big detractor for outside dining. Loved the diversity of the menu. Strong Italian dishes as well as steak. Great desert menu. Wine list was... More

Nicely decorated restaurant. Good food although the "lightly" breaded calamari was overly breaded. The diver scallops were large and nicely done. Prices are a bit on the high side. The "special" 2 for 1 margaritas were no bargain at $12 and only so so.