We dined at Belhurst in late June, '09. We were seated at a table that afforded a spectacular view across the lake and a tantalizing view of the manicured Belhurst grounds. We had driven up SR 14 from Watkins Glen in the early evening, and the scenery on this 35 mile trip with the sun illuminating the eastern shore of... more

I'm sorry to read the previous reviews on Belhurst and would like to say that we had a wonderful experience and a fantastic meal at Edgar's. We had dinner on weeknight (Tuesday) not the weekend when it is normally so busy. Our server was top-notch, informed about the meal choices and wine pairings. When I asked about local Finger Lakes... more

We were there just last month in August. Not knowing much about the restaurant, aside from its lofty-sounding name, "The Belhurst," we thought we were going to have a great experience. We were seated in a room, sequestered from other diners. That was not the issue, as we did appreciate the privacy this afforded us. But couldn't someone (management?) tell... more

I frequently go up to Geneva and eat at the Belhurst Castle...in their upscale restaurant as well as their more subdued Stonecutters. The setting is really very lovely, a treat during the summer. The staff in general is friendly. Eric at the restaurant bar is memorable, and there are some congenial staffers at Stonecutters.... The food is just average. During... more