Expensive meals. One of the few restaurants in town. Nothing spectacular about the interior. Convenient location.
Visited this restaurant in late March. There was a large party before us (hubby and another couple) and the wait staff seemed to be confused, trying to serve all....but they failed. Unfortunately, the food did not make up for the bad service.....and this was off-season! Food just ok, ambiance just ok....pasta a little over-done....vegetables were good and crunchy though. I... More
This was the first restaurant we tried in Cooperstown. The food was just ok. I had the lobster ravioli which was one of the items under the specialty list which tasted like it was a frozen product, and when we asked the server he said "they were made inhouse". Just the taste of lobster was inside, there were no actual... More
Excellent specials and a varied menu of Italian cuisine make Nicoletta's a tasty choice. The server was courteous, efficient and very responsive to our wants. The chocolate layer cake was most decadent!
Wonderful classic Italian food in a lovely setting. The bread is absolutely delicious! The entrees were fantastic - generous portions. Wish we had someplace to put the leftovers. The service was warm, friendly, and very attentive. Next time we are in town, we will definitely be back.
We need to come to this restaurant more often because the food and the service are absolutely fantastic. They have a very nice menu and if you love Italian Food you will definitely be happy dining here.
Great Italian/ Continental Menu with large portions, The house wine was excellent. The restaurant was recommended by our bed and breakfast where we were staying. The Tuscan salad is so authentic and the specialties that we had were outstanding
We have been to this restaurant in the past and had a wonderful meal. On New Year's Eve it was just average and the restaurant was not full as in the past. Prices seem to have come down a bit from when we were last there. There "cob-web" around the light fixture on the side wall that needs to be... More
Went to Nicoletta's on a damp, chilly November evening. Good food and friendly, casual service. Good food is nice, but cordial service brings this restaurant above the ordinary local Italian spot.
Friendly staff and delicious food. Portions are huge and well worth it. Must have their homemade sausage. To. Die. For. Will definitely go back when we come to town again.
If you own or manage Nicoletta's Italian Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing