There's a good variety of food, the service is average for a diner - there's not much of it, but you get what you need. I'm not the biggest fan of NY diners (I think NJ ones are better) but this one isn't bad... more

Favorite diner! more

went to this diner after movie ( hairspray) the food is good the prices got higher though -- it was average food for the $$$$ ah well what can I say its close to the movies if you dont want to venture too far for dinner/or snack more

it is overpriced(not inexpensive,as in "reviews" I ordered a sala(which was supposed to come with onions/scallions they had the nerve to charge for same & despite asking for cole slawwhich was missing from the salad-she never got me same more

Food was very dry, not to mention the bug on the plate... No server approached us until we received our check. That's not good!! Go to Olympic Diner, service is much better :) more

I live in Commack and have visited the Premier Diner numerous times. Each time has been enjoyable. The food is great and the service the same. I will continue to visit Premier over and over again. more

the food was dry, couldn't get the waitress to help us. Never saw her except to order then we got the check. I guess we could only have one drink each no one came by during the meal to see if we would like anything else or if the food was ok, So we couldnt send it back. They got... more

Long Island NY is packed with good diners but the Premier Diner in Commack at Exit 52 of the Long Island Expressway stands alone in its excellence. Everything about this diner screams superb customer service. You enter a beautiful polished aluminum building and are immediately greeted right inside the door by a distinguished gentleman standing on beatiful marble floors. The... more