We ordered a large pizza to go from here last weekend for $18.00. They wanted an extra $3.50 PER EXTRA TOPPING in addition to the $18 price. My spouse wanted to get onions but changed his mind when he saw the price. He couldn't believe the price gouging that they do here. Any other pizzeria would charge at most half... More

I cannot understand the hype and long lines. The pizza is average at best. The slices are small. There are many other better choices for pizza on the OC boardwalk.

We saw the line. We heard the rumors. We were excited to have this great pizza. We tried it and it was terrible. I mean how are people saying this is the best ever? I would rather buy frozen in the store.

This has been a favorite of ours for years. We live in Cape May County and get pizza here year round. Thin crust with a great sauce. Order ahead in the summer months, all locations are packed and have lines most of the time. (Can't get used to the new name, still refer to it as Mack & Manco)

No value here. What is all of the fuss. This is average pizza at best. Way over priced. The are several, twice as large slices and twice as good o the boardwalk. A waste of time and money.

I think the only reason this place stays alive is due to location and hype. Granted, finding a good pizza on OC is not easy. But almost any place is better than this one and a better value. They even charge for refills - seriously!

We always have the pizza at this restaurant. Its totally awesome and if there is a line, its worth the wait. Its cash only and a cheese pie is $17.00 at the time of this posting. Its worth every penny. Don't say its too expensive. After you eat it, you will want another one. When we stay at the Wild... More

always our first stop on the Boardwalk, its the best crispiest crust and tastiest pizza around! with three locations, and now another in nearby Somers Point, be sure to stop and get a pie, also the best, friendliest and most entertaining staff around!

hands down, without a doubt the finest pie to be found anywhere.Nothing wrong with Brooklyn or the other boroughs, Chicago is fine but this little place dishes out the freshest , hottest, thinnest pizza you will ever experience. Hint 4 locations on the boardwalk so if you hit a big line keep walking, you will find one with faster service