From appetizers to dessert everything was cooked fresh and delicious. Even my dinner which was the seafood in a cream sauce still tasted light because it was fresh. My boyfriend had the cajun swordfish special which melted in his mouth. Even though we were pretty full by the end, (we started with appetizers and salad) we still had room for... more

Oyster Bay is my favorite. The atmosphere is nice, the presentation excellent but the food is the star of the show. I have NEVER had a bad meal there and we go fairly often. The menu is well balanced, there is something for everyone. We have been going to Oyster Bay since shortly after there opening and have never left... more

a little pricey for what you get more

We went with friends on a whim. We must say we all loved it. About a month later in September we were talking with a friend who happened to say, you know where we had our best meal this summer, at Oyster Bay, we told them we have to agree. Best meal of the Summer 2008 !!!!!! more

Very Good solid 4 rating , the room is nice not outstanding . The Cajun seafood over linguine was very good but really didn't strike me as Cajun. more

We always ask the locals "what is your favorite restaurant?", and Oyster Bay was mentioned time and again. Now we can share our wonderful experience, too. The restaurant is quiet and romantically lit by candlelight, and beautifully decorated in a nautical theme (of course!). The service was friendly, prompt and attentive. And the food, aahh the food! All courses were... more

First night on our annual vacation, this is the MUST stop for dinner for us. This year was no different - and it was excellent. Yes the mozzarella salad was on special so that was an automatic. This year, tried the veal medallions and got a pleasant surprise. Not only were there three of them, but they were good sized,... more

Went here for the first time in 2005, and we have been hooked ever since. No trip to Cape May is complete without a meal at Oyster Bay. The atmosphere is comfortable, yet with a little fanciness. We feel like we're dining at a 5 star restaurant, but are able to wear comfortable shoes! The food is out of his... more

My friends and I decided to give Oyster Bay a try a few Friday nights ago. We were greeted by a very friendly hostess and seated in a dining room next to the bar. The room was decorated very nicely in a seashore theme. The martini's were awesome and the food was even better - large portions and cooked to... more