Stumpo''s is one of these places you go to eat when you can't decide where else to go. The food is always OK, service is always par, the price is fairly reasonable. My biggest complaint is that they cram an already small dining room with way too many tables. Be careful not to lean back in your chair because you'll... more

i've been there a few times, its not the most formal place and the food isn't that good. its an italian place and its like a crappy place that you'll go to just to have a dinner. no occasions. more

We have tried eating at Stumpo's twice and both times had decent traditional italian food. The downside is that they herd you in and out so quickly you don't have a chance to enjoy the food. The restaurant itself is very small with almost no atmosphere which is okay if the food and price make up for this shortcoming but... more

I always like the food at Stumpo's, and the last time I was there, we had a really great server. She was very attentive, the sort who didn't need to ask if you need another glass of water or silverware. The food was great - lots of flavor, good-sized portions. A little pricey, but it's Cape May. You expect to... more

Grab some take-out pizza from t his place. You definitely won't go wrong. My favorite in Cape May! I wouldn't recommend eating there... no frills and not impressive. The food, however, is. more

Couldn't get a seat inside, but we did get one on the back deck which was pleasant enough. Service was fast and friendly. The garlic bread bites are to die for -- forget your diet and eat them anyway. The pizza crust was excellent, but there was more cheese than I wanted. That's a personal preference, though, and others may... more

I have had pizza many many places in Cape May, but Stumpos is the best! My finance if the pickiest when it comes to Italian, and he would eat there anytime. He asked me when we go to Cape May on our honeymoon that we eat at Stumpos. more

The dinners we had were kind of bland and nothing worth noting, I would look elsewhere for Italian.. Cucina rosa was much better! more

My husband and I recently had dinner at Stumpo's and had an o.k. meal - not great but not horrible. The menu selection is excellent and the service was efficient although not overly friendly. We shared the steamed clams for an appetizer and they were tasty. We had rigatoni and penne pasta for our entrees and both were just average.... more