My husband and I have been going to Tisha's for the past several years. Even though we go there almost every Friday evening, it is always a special occassion. The food is always delicious and the people that work their are very friendly, professional, and go out of there way to please you. It is a very elegant but comfortable... more

Our party of eight dined at Tisha's on 8/25/09. We were celebrating a 30th wedding anniversary. We had a 6pm reservation, arrived 20 minutes early and were seated within 5 minutes. Off to a great start! Tisha's is BYOB so we brought wine and beer. Our server was somewhat reserved but attentive. She made sure we had ice immediately for... more

We made a reservation for dinner here a couple of weeks ago by leaving a telephone message (as instructed) but never got a call back from the restaurant to confirm. When we called them again, they said that they didn't have the reservation (despite the fact that we had left a message). Moreover, they were unapologetic bordering on surly when... more

My husband and I went out to eat at Tisha's during our stay in Cape May. We enjoyed excellent, attentive service and a great table with a beautiful view of the ocean. The food was great - my veal dish was a bit on the salty side but good nonetheless, my husband's filet was great. Portions were very generous, including... more

Not only did it take FOREVER to get our incredible bad food. But it also happened to give my whole family of four food poisoning. I have never been more disgusted and sick in my entire life. Literally thinking about what I ate there makes me sick to my stomach. I may have been ok with getting sick had the... more

This past week my family and I ate at a restaurant in Cape May called Tisha's Fine Dining. We picked it because it had a very good review in Zagat and it had nice view of the ocean. What a mistake. We did have a nice view, but it made us sick, literally. We all came down with food poisoning... more

We're just back from a great vaca in CM. We dined at Tishas with our 4 year old twin girls. The night we went was raining so we really could not appreciate the ocean view, but the service and food was fantastic..honestly was our best dinner in Cape May. The staff was friendly and the service was quick. They even... more

I am surprised to read the poor reviews of Tisha's. We come to CM every year and our meals at Tisha's are always fabulous. I love several CM restaurants, but Tisha's is my favorite. The lobster risotto is the best I've ever had. I have to say the dining room is tight and on humid nights it could get a... more

Terrible service. Had to go to the manager to request that my BYOB wine be opened because no waiter was in sighjt after 10 minutes of waiting. Took an our to get our house salads and another half-hour to get our entrees. more