Overall, very average for an Italian restaurant. Marinara sauce tasted and looked like it came out of a can of diced tomato's. No flavor at all. Meatballs and Sausage were very good.
We went to Fat Tony's for Dinner. We arrived at 6:00PM. The place was not busy. We were seated promptly. We each ordered a pizza. At about 6:45 the waitress came to the table and said my pizza had burned and they had to redo it. They brought the pizza that hadn't burned out so that my friend could have... More
Had a very good experience at Fat Tony's. Was passing through Rochester and decided to give it a try. It was well worth the stop. Good food, goid service and great prices. Give it a try!
We went to Rochester this last weekend and ate at Fat Tony's Saturday night. I had the steak tip and blue cheese salad - it was delicious. with the house merlot. The other guests also enjoyed their meals. for 4 of us to eat with drinks and dessert it came to $60! not each...TOTAL! and the server was lovely and... More
We went there again and this time for my darling wife's birthday. The server, she was fantastic. We asked for pasta w/o a tomato based sauce and she had the chef create a special sauce and it was excellent; they may even add it to the menu! My meal, the special w/pasta and chicken was good, but not fantastic. However,... More
Took 20 min to get a menu. 30 min to get a drink(we sat at the bar) the bartender/waitress/manager told us she "wasn't suppose to be there, didn't want to be there" she had other plans that night. Well it showed in the service we got. The food "sucked" I left 3/4 of my drink on the bar cause it... More
I dislike that everything tastes like it was thawed out in the microwave. I like the people and the location but think they would do themselves a real favor by hiring a chef
We went today for the first time in awhile and I am not sure if we will be back. We were the first customers there today for lunch and the service was good. The food was decent but the restaurant was very dirty. It appeared they are really letting it slide.
Visited and could not believe how happy everyone was with their meal. Pizza, Salad, Chicken Parm and dessert everything was great. Service was great and helpful. We will go back!
If you own or manage Fat Tony's Italian Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing